Contribution
As a neuroscientist, I congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Patel, on drawing attention to this timely issue. I declare an interest as founder and CEO of a biotech company, Neuro-Bio Ltd. Most recently, in collaboration with senior psychiatrists, we have been attempting to develop the first ever biomarker for depression, and we have done this in young people. This experience, working with clinicians and disturbed adolescents, has confirmed views I flagged in your Lordships’ House as far back as 2009 that digital technology was offering an alternative environment for the human condition.
Environment is key to individual development. Our species occupies more ecological niches than any other on the planet because of the superlative ability of our brains, compared with those of any other animal, to adapt to our surroundings. Even if you are a clone—an identical twin with the same genes—your brain becomes personalised through the development of unique configurations of connections between neurons that characterise the growth of the human brain after birth, curating a highly individual mind that is in constant dialogue with, and updated by, your unique life experiences.
Even before AI, it was increasingly apparent that screen usage would bring problems. It is not just the effects of not sleeping, not escaping the crowd and not having time to exercise that can facilitate obesity and bullying; the digital lifestyle can in and of itself prove deleterious. The more we depend on screen technologies as intermediaries for interpersonal relations while young, the less we learn the skills needed for effective communication and empathy in real-world interactions.
All too familiar are reports on how video games and social media can be deliberately crafted for commercial purposes to become addictive. The neuronal mechanism of addiction is an enhanced release of the chemical messenger dopamine, which underlies the anticipation of reward, raises arousal and is the hallmark, neurochemically, of recreational drugs. Dopamine inhibits a part of the brain—the so-called prefrontal cortex—that moderates emotional responses and dampens impulsive reactions. This region, just behind your forehead, is not fully operational until late teenage years or even the early 20s. Until then, characteristic features will include recklessness, a short attention span and, most significantly, overdependence on external stimulation. This mindset could well be exaggerated further by the perfect storm of a still immature prefrontal cortex coupled with unprecedented surges of inhibitory dopamine driven by a 21st-century screen lifestyle.
So we are faced with a set of dilemmas. Society desires young people to master and harness technology for the good of humanity, yet technology simultaneously drives mood deterioration, social exclusion, exploitation and trauma. The online world offers connection. AI holds promise at national and global levels, yet its unregulated integration into young people’s lives risks creating an entity increasingly alien to human emotional experience. The education system demands conformity to model answers, yet the modern world increasingly places a premium on creativity, independent thought and collaboration—skills the current system structurally undermines. Young people need community, shared purpose and belonging, yet the pull of influencer culture and online identity draws them away from real-world participation.
My psychiatrist colleagues were keen to suggest solutions—inevitably, with more money and more regulation. But perhaps we first need to agree on what the ideal teenage lifestyle would look like in the coming years. It is easy to list what we do not want but, unless we can decide on what we wish to achieve, it will be hard to attain it. Commonplace activities such as eating together, exercising, reading stories to children and immersing yourself in a novel may seem simplistic and nostalgic as solutions. Indeed they are, and they are not in themselves the answer, but they can be the bedrock for the development of emotions, intuition, empathy, morality, spirituality and, above all, spontaneous curiosity—a quintessential human profile not seen in AI systems. If you like, it is not a digital lifestyle but an analogue one. Let us ask not what will happen to us in the AI future but rather how we can shape a future where AI is neither an anthropomorphised spectre nor a saviour but a means towards the valued end of young people realising their full potential.