Contribution
My Lords, I join the chorus in thanking the noble Lord, Lord Patel, for securing this debate, and for his powerful introduction. I will take a different approach to many speeches already made: a broader, systemic, historically informed approach.
I begin with a quote:
“The Manufacture of this Nation hath been of late Years hindered … by the misspending so much Time as the poorer Tradesmen do, in going about from one Coffee-House to another, poring upon Seditious, Heretical and Treasonable Papers”.
As the language might hint to your Lordships’ House, that is from the very early 18th century. The presence of new technologies, and wide access of ordinary people to them, has long been of concern to elites, and to elders about the young. Technological determinism is a common claim and a handy alibi for those profiting from a society directed to the benefits of the few at the cost of the many. Technology never determines the direction of a society; it is a human creation that can be, and is, directed by humans for good or ill—as is the state of our society.
I will start with screen time. The noble Lord, Lord Patel, asked an entirely appropriate question about the health impacts—my spine can attest to that—but what alternatives do young people have? Is there a youth club for them to go to? Almost certainly not. Is there a flourishing, healthy green space to attract them? No. Does their school in some giant academy chain employ tech instead of trained teachers, so that, despite the lack of evidence of any benefits, it relies on edtech?
Earlier this week, at a meeting of the APPG for Woods and Trees, I heard a nurseryman lamenting the decline of horticultural and agricultural education: the colleges that should be preparing young people for crucial, healthy jobs. How often do we hear Ministers or the Prime Minister speaking about this, compared with them waxing enthusiastically about the possibilities of artificial so-called intelligence—promoting it, and suggesting that it is an inevitable part of future jobs, so directing young people towards it?
We have extraordinarily well-funded and powerful voices, some of them owning and directing the very technologies we are talking about, who promote AI and social media at every turn. We have them funding so-called think tanks—better called lobbyists—following the models of political influencing developed by the fossil fuel companies and the tobacco merchants of death. As the noble Lord, Lord Addington, and the noble Baroness, Lady Wheatcroft, have said, this tech can be, and is, used for good. It can be a democratising force—yes, I am a fan of Bluesky.
These days, it is common to complain that there is too much information; Duran Duran sang about that in 1993—although, when you look at the lyrics of the song, it is actually about advertising. That is a reminder that a lot of the toxic material our young people are encountering—the promotion of ultra-processed food-like substances, fast fashion, and tech itself—is from giant multinational companies. Blame them, not the technology.
Finally, we come to the question of the environmental footprint of these technologies. Some communities on these islands and around the world are increasingly aware of this issue and are campaigning against it. These technologies are not in the cloud; they are very much down to earth, causing real damage to the already greatly depleted world our young people will inherit. Are the Government considering how much of all these technologies our environment and the environments of the world can support?
In conclusion, we have a toxic artificial intelligence and social media environment that harms adults and children. That comes from a toxic society. What to do? Listen to the children: nothing about us without us. They are the experts. As in so many areas of life, allowing more people to input into decisions, rather than the few dictating, is the route to a better society.