L

Lord Clement-Jones (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 22 October 2026

Debate

AI, Screen Usage and Social Media: Effect on Children

Contribution

My Lords, I warmly thank the noble Lord, Lord Patel, for securing the debate and for the authority with which he opened it. We have heard a series of outstanding speeches on a very broad range of issues, as the noble Baroness, Lady Murphy, pointed out. Like the noble Lord, Lord Hampton, I was absolutely delighted to hear from the noble Lord, Lord McFall, who was a very technology-savvy Lord Speaker, understanding both the opportunities and risks of tech for this House during his tenure. On many occasions, I have asked whether this technology will be our servant or master. Today, that question has a rather sharper edge: is this technology serving childhood, or are our children being shaped to serve a business model built on attention? Are we being invaded in our domestic lives, as the noble Lord, Lord Rees, said; or, as the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Peterborough said, is it serving their humanity? The debate is no longer about whether to act; it is about whether what we do is well-designed, grounded in evidence and able to keep pace with AI. At its heart is one principle: safety by design. The question is not only which children we keep off which platforms but whether the products themselves are built with children’s well-being in mind. What does the evidence tell us? The POST briefings were mentioned by the noble Lord, Lord Patel. They were published in August and show the scale of the situation. By the age of 2, 98% of children use screens on a typical day, and 97% of 13 to 17 year-olds have a social media or messaging profile. Some harms are found consistently: disrupted sleep, sedentary behaviour, obesity—mentioned by the noble Lord, Lord Brooke—myopia and the security risks mentioned by the noble Baroness, Lady Manningham-Buller. However, POST is equally clear that most studies take a snapshot at a single point in time, so they show a link, but not a cause and effect. The harm lies, therefore, not just in the content but in the functionality of the product: infinite scroll, autoplay, streaks and recommender systems tuned for engagement, and recommender systems tuned to maximise engagement rather than well-being, triggering the brain effects mentioned by the noble Baroness, Lady Greenfield. These are deliberate design choices, and they can be designed differently. A ban asks children to stay away from unsafe products; safety by design, as the noble Baroness, Lady Owen, advocated, requires companies to stop building them. However, we should not forget the benefits, which were mentioned not only by my noble friend Lord Addington but by the noble Baronesses, Lady Wheatcroft, Lady Owen and Lady Bennett, and the noble Lords, Lord Loomba and the Lord Rees. The OxWell survey found that one in eight students use social media for mental health support, rising to around a quarter among some of the most vulnerable groups. Australia’s early evaluation, also mentioned by the noble Baronesses, Lady Wheatcroft and Lady Owen, found a fall in accounts on restricted platforms, but that many children had kept access. A blunt instrument can miss its target and hurt the very children it is meant to protect. We should listen to the children’s charities here. The NSPCC has warned us that a complex problem needs more than a blanket solution. The risk is that children are pushed through VPNs into less regulated spaces, where they are harder to protect, and then meet the full force of the most addictive features the day they turn 16. The Secretary of State acknowledged that cliff-edge concern, but the same thinking should apply to younger children too, because many will get round the ban or use services it does not cover, and safer design is what protects them there. That is why we on the Liberal Democrat Benches have argued for film-style age ratings for social media. Platforms with harmful content or addictive algorithmic feeds would be rated over-16, and extreme content 18-plus, while educational sites and family messaging would stay open. No child should be banned from Wikipedia for their homework or from the family WhatsApp group. We have also called for health warnings on apps and a cap on doom scrolling. There is a range of views about the right age threshold, but we share the same goal. The Government’s package reflects some of the thinking behind our approach, and the noble Lord, Lord Nagaraju, set some of that out—targeting harmful features rather than screens alone, and safer defaults for 16 and 17 year- olds. They have chosen a blanket ban where we would have preferred ratings, but a ratings approach should still shape how the ban is defined and enforced, so that it is the riskier services that are caught. Let me turn to artificial intelligence, which has been mentioned by so many noble Lords and which I fear will be the next frontier of this debate, long after a social media ban has bedded in. As the noble Baroness, Lady Prashar, says, we need to act now. Ofcom has said plainly that chatbots are not regulated at all where users interact only with the bot, and that extending its powers is a matter for government and Parliament. The Online Safety Act regulates services, not technology, and generative AI exposes that gap. The Government’s fix is welcome, but too narrow. Illegal content duties and an age limit on romantic companion bots leave untouched the sycophancy, emotional dependency and manipulative design of general-purpose chatbots, which children increasingly treat as friends, tutors and confidants, as we have heard from noble Lords today. POST also notes potential risks to attention, language development and independent thinking. AI should strengthen children’s thinking, not substitute for it. These are design choices, too. A chatbot that flatters, never ends a conversation and presents itself as a friend has been built that way. Will the Government look at default design duties rather than relying on illegal content duties alone? I suggest four steps. The first should be the adoption of the proposals in the recent report from the Joint Committee on Human Rights, of which the noble Lord, Lord Alton, was chair. This would involve mandatory children’s algorithmic impact assessments before AI products were likely to be used by children. Secondly, there should be a statutory children and AI design code, building on the age-appropriate design code. Many noble Lords have mentioned the opportunities for AI in education, but there should be human-in-command standards for AI in schools and edtech. I commend strongly the recent book by Daniel Susskind, What Should My Children Do? and, of course, all the work that Sir Anthony Seldon and Michael Stevenson are carrying out at Wellington College on human flourishing and education. Fourthly, there should be age assurance that protects privacy and is built on open standards. I should also mention, as the noble Lord, Lord Rees, did, the importance of avoiding cognitive offloading in higher education in particular, and the steps that need to be taken to make sure that we use AI tools but that we also educate in a way that forces people not to be able to use AI tools but keep the critical thinking that is so vital. I have some questions for the Minister. First, will the Section 214A regulations be made by affirmative procedure, with a draft published for consultation, and will the end of the year timetable hold? Secondly, which services are in and which are out? YouTube disputes that it is social media, and WhatsApp sits outside the ban. Will there be an independent risk-based rating mechanism rather than a ministerial list? Thirdly, how will privacy be protected in age assurance and how will VPN circumvention be handled? The Government also said they would legislate for age verification at device level if their recommendations were not adopted by September this year. That deadline has passed. Can the Minister tell the House what has happened and whether legislation is now coming? Fourthly, will the regulations and Ofcom codes impose positive design duties so that services likely to be used by children are safe by design, as the Online Safety Act’s own objectives require? As the noble Baroness, Lady Armstrong, asked, what about digital inclusion? Other noble Lords talked about media literacy. The new RSHE guidance taught from this September covers online misogyny, AI and deepfakes. What support will teachers get to deliver it with confidence, and will independent evaluation be built in from day one? Childhood should not be a product optimised for engagement. Our aim is not simply to keep children out of the digital world but to require that it is built safe for them from the start: technology that serves childhood rather than dominates it. As the noble Lord, Lord McFall, said about what Stuart Russell had to say when he came to the Lords about the power of tech companies, we should heed him. We need a culture of safety, and we need regulation to back it up.

More from Lord Clement-Jones (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.