Contribution
My Lords, we are most grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Patel, for securing this important debate.
Throughout the passage of the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act, my noble friend Lady Barran successfully argued that social media, mobile phones and screens in general were largely detrimental to children, a view which we steadfastly hold. We drew on evidence from teachers, parents and experts which concluded that the use of these devices risked worse social skills, worse mental health and worse results.
The Government acknowledged that conclusion, and from the start of this academic year, schools should be mobile phone-free environments by default. Regulations will soon be laid to ban under-16s from the negative effects of social media. In both these measures there is an implicit acknowledgement that screens in fact do not benefit children but have the potential to cause active harm.
For that reason, it is of grave concern that worrying elements of educational technology remain in the school system. The government guidance is clear: no mobile phones in schools. Additional guidance states that anything other than this should be by exception only. With the presence of edtech in classrooms, screens are anything but an exception. Now 11% of pupils use an individual device in every lesson, while nearly 40% use screens in schools every day.
The noble Baroness, Lady Wheatcroft, was quite right that this is not the way that relationships are built. The noble Baroness, Lady Armstrong, referenced this as a nuanced subject, which is right. To be clear, we are not conflating mobile phones with educational technology. There are notable exceptions when edtech helps—for example, with special education needs pupils. However, the medically proven distractions that are considered detrimental in respect of use of mobile phones are too often prevalent in the edtech that is supposed to facilitate learning.
Homework apps may prioritise interaction over learning and treat schooling as a reward-based enterprise versus essential learning for self-improvement. This would be no issue if using screens produced better learning and better results. However, these devices have proven the exact opposite. Studies have found that students spending two-thirds of every hour off-task while using a laptop in educational settings is a regular occurrence and that it can take students up to 20 minutes to refocus on a task following a distraction. This is a well-known fact.
The noble Baroness, Lady Wheatcroft, highlighted a school which uses no devices for teaching. It is a fact that comprehension increases by up to 60% if students read on print rather than digitally. Benefits to mathematical learning become pronounced only in the upper secondary school years after students have developed sufficient foundational knowledge and cognitive maturity to engage productively with the demands of virtual experimentation. Again, this is a fact.
I greatly enjoyed the excellent contribution from the noble Baroness, Lady Greenfield, with her neuroscience background. Her fellow neuroscientist, the best-selling author, Dr Jared Horvath, has demonstrated that independent schools in England and Wales, which use relatively the most educational technology, have been declining in PISA scores by 21% per decade—a phenomenon which is offset by improving state schools, which have, unfortunately, less access to some of the edtech.
This outcome should not be a surprise to noble Lords. While no consensus has been reached regarding edtech’s benefits and only 7% of companies have conducted controlled trials, schools have been left with the responsibility of weighing the costs and benefits of procurement in line with their longer-term strategies. The right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Peterborough argued that we owe it to our educators. The noble Baroness, Lady Murphy, rightly challenged the Minister on the very same subject. Schools are left to navigate an uncontrolled experiment while edtech companies have little oversight of their actions.
These are big tech companies. The noble Lord, Lord Alton, flagged that some of them have larger market capitalisations than the entire GDP of many national economies. The noble Lord, Lord McFall, reminded us that AI, bizarrely, is less regulated than milk or washing machines. As a minimum, the industry must have some kind of centralised oversight. Will the Minister commit to such regulatory scrutiny, in line with the request of the noble Lord, Lord Tarassenko, to be measured in months, not years?
There is, rightfully, much interest around the benefits that new technologies can bring to learning and working. We are not suggesting that technology cannot be used to improve schooling, or children’s lives in general, but simply that it must be rigorously tested before it is rolled out and then overseen when it is.
On artificial intelligence, 90% of children already use AI for entertainment, while 85% use it for schoolwork. There are undoubtedly benefits to introducing children to new technologies as they enter into a world built by them, but, surely, unfettered access and use can be incredibly damaging during a child’s core development years. Studies show that early protracted exposure to AI can interfere with long-term memory and learning processes. More generally, there is a risk that AI creates a generation of children dependent on outsourcing their thinking, which has been referenced by many noble Lords. Much like educational technology, AI must be most beneficial when its users have acquired the foundational knowledge and maturity needed to deal with that very technology.
The Government are implementing an AI strategy in schools as evidence emerges, but we would suggest to the Minister that we need more. The pace of change in this sector is like nothing we have seen before, and other countries are acting: the OECD and the European Commission have co-published the AI literacy framework, and over 35 US states now have official AI guidance. When will this Government follow their lead?
I will end on concerns of AI becoming edtech by the back door. There are a number of schools already using AI learning assistants in lessons. It is so incredibly important, as was referenced by the noble Lord, Lord Clement-Jones, to give children the best start in life, and the Government’s approach must be evidence based and balanced. The education sector is facing a torrent of new and untested technologies. Some will be beneficial, but others will not, and it is surely absolutely critical to get this right for everyone involved.