L

Lord Garnier (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 27 October 2026

Debate

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Contribution

Well, we may now be getting to a point of agreement; we should be looking at the six statutes of Edward III, because that is where a proper interpretation of Clause 39 of Magna Carta comes. That said—gosh, can I get to the church by way of the moon?—what is more important in the development of our jury system is not what happened in the Middle Ages but what happened in the post-Civil War period with the Mead and Penn case, the development of the Bill of Rights and universal education, the increase in the economic power of our country, the removal of power from the Crown and the Barons to the wider population and the involvement of that wider population in our justice system through the jury. It is important that we recognise the democratic input that the jury system provides in our criminal justice system. I agree with my noble friend Lord Howard that it is also important to remind ourselves what the previous Lord Chancellor and Secretary of State for Justice, David Lammy, did in introducing this whole subject in the first place. I have some sympathy for the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson, who has twice now been asked to carry out inquiries and write reports for two different Governments, and has not found that they have met universal approval by the politicians. I am afraid that that is the fate of report writers. I have had that problem myself, but I have borne it with such fortitude as I have been able to muster. The serious point, however, is this. Mr Lammy asked himself the wrong question and then came up with the wrong answer to the wrong question. The question he ought to have asked himself is: what, in practical terms —I look across to the noble Lord, Lord McNicol—can best be done to reduce the backlog of cases in our criminal justice system? Bear in mind that only 10% of all criminal cases get before the Crown Court. As I think the noble Baroness, Lady Levitt, said, the magistrates carry out the bulk of our criminal justice work. They are to be praised and supported, their work is to be reinforced with adequate resources and decent premises, and so on and so forth. However, I suspect you are not going to reduce the backlog, which now, we are told, stands at 81,000 cases, by reducing the ability of the citizen to get a trial in front of a jury. Certainly the non-violent cases will be pushed back well beyond 2029 or 2030 at the current rate. Let us think of one or two practical points beyond those that the noble Lord mentioned a moment ago. I confess that I used to sit as a Crown Court recorder. As a civil law practitioner, it may well be wondered by people such as the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson, what on earth I was doing in a criminal court. I see that the great god of time has already enabled me to curtail my remarks, when I know that the whole House is absolutely itching to hear what I have to say. The time will come in Committee when we will have to dismantle this Bill and reconstruct it in such a way that we can reduce the backlog but without reducing access to justice. Unless we pay attention to the state of the buildings and the ability of the delivery service to get people from remand to the Crown Court in time without having enough judges, part-time or full-time, or enough court staff, all the things that the Government think that this reform will do will be lost, because the same mechanical problems will still exist.

More from Lord Garnier (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.