L

Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 27 October 2026

Debate

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Contribution

My Lords, this has been a powerful debate, memorably marked by the excellent maiden speech of noble Lord, Lord Stace, which certainly did not support a diagnosis of imposter syndrome. It was a pleasure to hear his measured endorsement of the open discussion of difficult issues with people of differing views—that is exactly what we hope to achieve in this House. It was also a pleasure to hear the powerful speech of the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson, whose report has so influenced the Government and this Bill, including his unanswerable assertion that we need a combination of increased funding, structural reform and increased efficiency. My noble friend Lady Brinton spoke to the issues facing victims in the criminal justice system. I will speak to the Bill’s more controversial proposals for that system, and on an issue that I believe should be, but is not, covered by the Bill. The noble Lord, Lord Macdonald, and others are clearly right that we are trying to respond to the years of underfunding that have led to the appalling backlog of 80,000 cases awaiting Crown Court trials. However, it is not proven that restricting jury trials would markedly reduce the backlog. Take into account, for example, that judges would be spending time writing judgments and that appeals would proliferate. Effective measures to reduce delays should include increased sitting days, reliable prisoner transport, maintaining the courts, and smarter use of new technology for listing and case management. As the Minister said, the Government have successfully set out on this process. Trying two cases in longer court hours over two sessions a day, as mentioned by my noble friend Lady Brinton, would significantly cut delays. The Crown Court backlog has now stabilised, as the noble Baroness, Lady Mallalieu, pointed out. From January to June, it rose by just 367 cases—0.46%. Although the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson, has some arguments with the interpretation of the present figures, there are still ways of cutting the backlog that do not involve the entire suite of proposals in the Bill. Yes, we must reduce it further, but why have the Government not revised their projections, given the recent improvement of which the Minister spoke and which the figures suggest? The noble and learned Lords, Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd and Lord Garnier, pointed out that we need more reliable and fuller information before we pass the Bill. The serious problem is now in the magistrates’ courts, with a backlog in June, even excluding single justice procedure cases, of about 169,000 cases—up 16% in a year. Yet the proposals in the Bill, removing the right to elect jury trials and increasing magistrates’ sentencing powers, would transfer to them many more cases, and they would be the bigger and more time-consuming ones. In addition, the threat to jury trials has not disappeared. First, there is the removal of the right to elect. Along with the noble Baroness, Lady Levitt, I accept that there is some evidence of hardened criminals gaming the system and electing for jury trial for bad reasons: to delay the trial, to weaken prosecution evidence, or to build up credit for time on remand or under bail conditions Some pretty trivial cases do come to the Crown Court, but the gaming of the system could be addressed, partly at least, by increasing the discount for an early guilty plea, as the noble Baroness, Lady Kennedy, suggested. We believe that the right to elect a trial by jury is a cornerstone of our liberty. Juries democratise criminal justice, as the noble and learned Lord, Lord Garnier, the noble Baroness, Lady Kennedy, and others have said. The public trust juries. They think the system fair. They believe that 12 heads are better than one. They know different judges will reach different conclusions on the same evidence. They see judges as liable to be influenced by their own prejudices, social backgrounds and beliefs, as the noble Lord, Lord Russell said. The Bill proposes an allocation by magistrates alone, with no right of appeal. However, the best people to decide on allocation are Crown Court judges, who hear jury trials all the time, not magistrates who lack that experience. Denying appeals on allocation is unfair. Along with the noble Lord, Lord Howard, I believe there should be a clear distinction between persons of hitherto good character, who would suffer irreparable harm to their reputation, careers and relationships from any conviction, and seasoned offenders, for whom the consequences of conviction are limited to the sentence imposed. There are further practical pitfalls to removing the right of election, going beyond the pressure on magistrates’ courts from increased case numbers, as was well explored by the noble Lords, Lord Macdonald and Lord Carlile, and the noble Baroness, Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb. Legal aid is far more restricted in magistrates’ courts than in the Crown Court. If magistrates are to handle more and heavier cases, we must improve the availability of legal aid, just as the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of St Edmundsbury and Ipswich argued. Lack of representation in the magistrates’ courts is a recipe for inefficient and over-lengthy hearings, and for unfairness and unsafe convictions. Unsafe or unjust convictions will lead to more appeals, overburdening the Crown Court. I turn to trial by judge alone in so-called complex or lengthy cases. The expectation was that this be just for long and complex cases of financial crime, as per the initial list in the Bill. Certainly, some fraud trials are extremely complex, but not all of them. Good, clear presentation by a competent prosecution team, using new presentational technology, and limiting the indictment to reflect the defendant’s criminality, can usually reduce both complexity and trial length. More importantly, the issues in even these cases are so often typical jury issues. What did she know? Did he sign that document, or was his signature a forgery? Was her behaviour dishonest or not? These are typical, human jury issues. As for trial length, we cope with lengthy trials now, and a modest increase in jury expenses, after a certain time had elapsed, would ease the burden. While I accept that there are complex financial cases that could be tried by judge alone, they are not many. But the Bill has a nasty sting in the tail regarding “judge alone” trials. The initial list of offences in Schedule 1 is a list of financial crimes. Homicide offences and sexual offences would be expressly excluded, but that should be obvious. However, the express exclusion of those cases suggests a threat that the Government could go far further than fraud and complex financial cases. That is the point of the insidious and dangerous power in Part 1 of the schedule: to add any non-excluded offence to the list of “judge alone” offences—the “Joseph Stalin clause”, as the noble Lord, Lord Howard described it. The hard-won victory of campaigners against the restriction of jury trials originally proposed is to be at the mercy of an order from the Secretary of State. That is unacceptable. Next, there is the proposed increase in the sentencing powers of magistrates. Again, that would lead to a massive transfer of cases to the magistrates’ courts, increasing the pressure on the magistrates and increasing the risk that defendants will be unrepresented and wrongly convicted or excessively harshly sentenced. I turn now to an issue that should have been addressed in this Bill but is not. The noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson, made a number of important recommendations in his report that have not found their way into this Bill. He devoted his first 10 recommendations to diversions. He recognised that criminal courts may not be the best forum for handling low-level offences, and so recommended the greater use of out-of-court resolutions. He spoke of cautions, conditional cautions and other mechanisms for disposal, of rehabilitation programmes for drug and alcohol abuse, and of other health interventions. We should be keeping far more low-level offenders, both children and adults, out of the criminal justice system when it is plain that their problems should be handled constructively and with sympathy, rather than through blunt and often profoundly unhelpful recourse to the criminal courts. The Minister, and the former Minister, the noble Lord, Lord Timpson, have been very supportive of alternative disposals or out-of-court resolutions—both unattractive names for a far more constructive approach than we have at present. I believe that this thinking should reflect our approach not only at the charging stage. Courts should be bound to consider, early in the criminal process, out-of-court resolutions in place of fully fledged criminal proceedings, much as civil courts consider mediation. There is potential either to hard bake criminality into the lives of low-level offenders, as we do at present, or to have a more humane and sensitive system. This thinking can be extended to many areas. Take, as one example, unauthorised absence, by which parents who fail to ensure their children’s attendance at school are prosecuted under the Education Act 1996, are liable to be fined and, in extreme cases, can be sentenced to imprisonment. Yet so many of these cases concern children who simply will not go to school, for medical or psychological reasons, however hard their parents try to get them there. They need a therapeutic approach, not a penal one. A film on this topic of unauthorised absence is to be given a parliamentary screening in December. We have to change our approach not just to this but to other low-level offences that put people at risk of inappropriate prosecution. It is not just too many offences that clog up our courts; it is the mindset of a system that has long been too unadventurous to limit criminal proceedings to the cases where they are necessary and appropriate.

More from Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.