L

Lord Keen of Elie (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 27 October 2026

Debate

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I begin by welcoming the noble Lord, Lord Stace, to his place in this House and congratulate him on his maiden speech. I look forward to him bringing his extensive experience and knowledge not only to the consideration of this Bill in Committee but to the wider proceedings of this House. I hope I do not misrepresent his views if I infer from his speech that he does not believe that the crisis in criminal prosecution begins at the door of the court but could more properly be addressed by considering the economic and social issues that allow a younger generation to drift into criminality in the first place—in other words, that we should consider root causes rather than just effects. In an early speech, the noble and learned Lord, Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd, posited a series of alternative court mechanisms for addressing the backlog—what might be termed “Leveson 3”, albeit not a welcome prospect to the noble and learned Lord in his seat. That is perhaps beyond the ambit of the present Bill. I seek to address the recognition, noted by my noble friend Lord Ashcombe, that there are significant backlogs in our criminal court system. Of course, we agree that they must be addressed—not only from the perspective of the victims of crime but from the perspective of those accused of crime. They should not have to wait year after year to determine their future, whether they are on remand or otherwise. They, too, are entitled to a reasonably swift resolution of accusations of crime made against them. But timely justice cannot come at the cost of the right to trial by jury, which, in turn, if interfered with, is liable to undermine public trust and confidence in the justice system. We are concerned that the power proposed by the Bill would seriously undermine public confidence in the justice system. These proposals will weaken that confidence. The Government began to recognise that serious problem in the other place, when they proceeded to remove Clause 3 of the original Bill, but they have not gone far enough. I express my concern and agreement with the noble and learned Lord, Lord Garnier, that, given the changes made to the Bill, there was simply insufficient consideration or scrutiny of the Bill in the other place. That seems to be a serious concern, albeit we are capable of operating effectively as a House that can review legislation from the other place. We have serious concerns that the criminal justice system should be the subject of detailed consideration by both Houses of Parliament. Particular concern has been expressed across the House with regard to the right to elect a jury trial in “either way” cases and the impact of this and other measures on the magistrates’ court. I wish just to touch upon the views expressed right across the House on that issue. The noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, began by referring to the situation in the magistrates’ courts as “significantly worse” than it is in the Crown Courts. We heard from my noble friend Lady Sater about there being something of the order of 380,000 open cases. The noble Lord, Lord Russell, referred to the dangers of the magistrates’ courts being overwhelmed. The noble Lord, Lord McNicol of West Kilbride, questioned the capacity of the magistrates’ court to take on the additional court cases. Indeed, he pointed out the need for a plan, a point made repeatedly by noble Lords during the debate. My noble and learned friend Lord Garnier commended the practical approach that the noble Lord, Lord McNicol, took to the issue. The noble Lord, Lord Macdonald of River Glaven, asked what modelling had been done to determine the impact of these changes on the magistrates’ court. As far as we can see, there has been little or none. The noble Baroness, Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb, talked about there being “insufficient evidence” to support these proposed changes. The noble Baroness, Lady Fox, asked whether there is any evidence that we are not simply shifting the problem to the magistrates’ courts. The noble Baroness, Lady Mallalieu, talked about the damage to public confidence if the shift was made without adequate resourcing within the magistrates’ court system—not just buildings, magistrates or legal advisers but the provision of suitable legal assistance, which requires, in turn, that the issue of legal aid within the magistrates’ courts be addressed. None of this has happened. My noble and learned friend Lord Bellamy simply posed the question: how are the magistrates’ courts going to cope with the increased caseload? Again, there has been no assessment of how that is going to be dealt with. There was a reference to the fact that we are recruiting 2,000 more magistrates, but when are they going to be trained and available? How are they going to cope in the meantime? The noble Baroness, Lady Kennedy of The Shaws, asked whether there had been conversations with the magistrates in any detail about how the impact would be dealt with. There are no answers. I invite the Minister to provide answers, and if he cannot do it this evening, to do it in writing and in detail, because, clearly, this issue has touched Members of the House on each side. We then had the issue of whether there should be the removal of juries for complex and lengthy trials. I was rather taken by the observation from the noble and learned Lord, Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd, who said that, generally speaking, in complex financial cases and cases of fraud, the issue is honesty. What better than a jury to determine issues of honesty? Indeed, that was a point made by the noble Baroness, Lady Kennedy of The Shaws, in her address to your Lordships’ Chamber. That is the central issue in these cases, I agree, but it is one pre-eminently suitable for a jury of one’s peers. Then there is the question of the possible expansion of the definition of “complex or lengthy cases” through secondary legislation, not even with an express provision that it would be dealt with by the affirmative procedure. My noble friend Lord Howard referred to it as “monstrous”. Indeed, the noble Baroness, Lady Chakrabarti, expressed concern about the removal of the “safety valve” by this provision and what happens when we have a Government of a potentially authoritarian bent who could then utilise such a power. The noble Baroness, Lady Fox, referred to it as outrageous. Even the noble Lord, Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames, deemed it unacceptable. Therefore, I invite the Government to think again on that issue. If they do not do so then, again, I suspect we shall revisit this at a later stage. I turn to the removal of the presumption of parental involvement. There, I adopt the expert views expressed by my noble friend Lady Barran. It seems to me that the Government are aiming at the wrong target; this was a point brought out by my noble friend Lord Farmer and the noble Baroness, Lady Fox. There is no intent to elevate parental rights above the welfare of a child, but the idea that the presumption is somehow causative of some of the terrible events that have been spoken of not only is unproven but appears, on the face of it, improbable. This is a very badly targeted remedy, if it be a remedy at all. Therefore, again, I urge the Minister to reconsider. The Government’s original plans were clearly unacceptable. Indeed, my noble friend the Leader of the Opposition was explicit when, in the debate on the King’s Speech earlier this year, he pointed out that the whole issue of blocking jury trial had never been mentioned in any manifesto, and that, accordingly, we would exercise the full freedoms of this House to defend that right. The Bill contains provisions on the right of election to trial by jury and the removal of jury trial in complex cases. Again, these were never the subjects of any manifesto commitment. Of course, we are a scrutinising Chamber, and progress is best achieved through close engagement between Ministers and Members of your Lordships’ House. We on this side of the House are certainly committed to working as constructively as possible with the Minister to deliver a Bill that can improve the issue of the backlog in the court system—one not just limited to the Crown Court but extending to the magistrates’ court. I am reminded of a remark made very early on in this debate by the noble Lord, Lord Macdonald of River Glaven, when he said that the origins of this are a funding crisis. Perhaps we need to address that, as well as these provisions.

More from Lord Keen of Elie (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.