Contribution
My Lords, the purpose of this Bill is to cut through the fog of uncertainty that now hangs over the Chagos Islands to provide a fairer, clearer and more principled way forward for not simply the Chagos Islands themselves but, perhaps more importantly, the Chagossians—and I am delighted that many of them are able to join us here today.
Like many in this Chamber, I was, and remain, highly critical of the previous government Bill on this issue. Without rehearsing all the arguments that were used in connection with that Bill, which sought to implement the Government’s deal with Mauritius, I believe that that Bill would have, in effect, handed over sovereign territory that had been British for more than 200 years to a Government who had never held control or ownership of the islands. Indeed, it did not simply give away the Chagos Islands but presented Mauritius with a large dowry—a very handsome reward—for taking the islands off our hands, without even a compensatory automatic right of resettlement for the Chagossians.
That Bill gave no agency to the Chagossian people themselves, and for many Chagossians that is all too familiar. At times, in our most benign interpretations as a Parliament and as Governments, we have perhaps pretended that we are doing things for the Chagossian people, but far too often we have done things to the Chagossian people—most notably in the 1960s, when they were forcibly removed from the islands. What we have not done—this is what we need to change—is do things with the Chagossian people, respecting their choice and their control over their destiny.
The criticism that has been made of the previous Bill has not been confined to this House. As we have seen recently, even the new Defence Secretary, Wes Streeting, has questioned whether the previous Bill was good enough, given the position of the Americans. The current Prime Minister, who, to be fair to him, played no part in the previous arrangements, has indicated that there needs to be a review of the overall Bill. We know that the progress of the previous Bill was stopped by the position of the American Administration. I appreciate that, at times, many of us in this Chamber see a level of volatility within the American Administration and their foreign policy. However, they have been consistent over the last period of time in their concern that this is not the right way forward. Given the direct interest of the American Administration, through the military base at Diego Garcia, this is not simply an opinion from across the Atlantic but something that is critical to the way forward for the Chagos Islands.
As a result, the issue has been left in a form of limbo. The Government, it would appear, have not resiled from their previous position and potentially remain committed to the Bill, despite the review. But, by the same token, they were not able to bring forward that Bill to progress it whenever it was going through the Lords. Indeed, in the last King’s Speech, there was no mention of the situation as regards the Chagos Islands. In particular, this has left the Chagossians in a form of political purgatory. They have been left with a level of uncertainty. The one thing that we owe above all else to the Chagossian people is certainty and control for the future. That is the purpose of my Bill.
I will outline the contents of the Bill. Although it is relatively short, it has five main components. First, crucially, it provides what might be described as a triple lock on sovereignty—either the transfer of sovereignty or the leasing out of the islands. Before that can happen, for any deal three hurdles have to be overcome. First, it would have to be done by way of an Act of Parliament. Secondly, if there is a representative Government of the Chagossian people, it would have to have their approval. Most crucially, in enshrining the principle of self-determination of the Chagossian people, it would have to be approved by a referendum of the Chagossian people, with the electorate clearly defined in Clause 4, which highlights that British Indian Ocean Territory citizens would have the right to vote in that referendum. This would put the destiny of the Chagos Island and the Chagossian people in their own hands, which is the right thing to do.
Secondly, one of the major concerns in relation to the Chagos Islands has clearly been the military base at Diego Garcia, which is the overriding concern of the Americans and is strategically very important to us. The Bill clearly and explicitly indicates that, whatever rulings may happen in the future, the base itself remains sovereign British territory. It gives a clear sign of certainty about the position of Parliament and the sovereign position.
Thirdly, the Bill enshrines transparency in any future arrangements. Clause 2 deals with the fact that, if there is any proposal to hand over to Mauritius or anyone else, any financial arrangements, both with the Mauritian Government and with agencies or any companies connected with them, are clearly outlined to Parliament. There has been a level of disagreement, shall we say, over the extent of the financial aid that was being given over to Mauritius within that.
Fourthly and importantly, there is the role of the Chagossian people. Although it is critical that we enshrine the rights of self-determination, simply giving the Chagossians a yes or no on any final package is not in and of itself sufficient. So the Bill looks at what other pertinent rights we can give the Chagossian people. It deals with permits to work on the Diego Garcia base and, in particular, with a critical issue for the Chagossians: resettlement. They were torn from their country in the 1960s, and the Bill explicitly gives a right to resettle permanently on Île du Coin and Île Boddam—I apologise to the Chagossians if my pronunciation is not up to scratch—as well as on Diego Garcia itself if at any stage the base there is in some way abandoned.
Allied to and part of that resettlement, the Government would be compelled to discuss with and consult the Chagossian people on a range of issues—from an economic partnership to a partnership on skills, health and education; marine conservation and biodiversity; and the protection of Chagossian culture. So it will be part of putting the Chagossian people at the heart of any level of discussion, because too often in the past they have been regarded as an afterthought, brought in at best to be told what has happened after it has happened. I do not believe that that is an acceptable way forward.
Fifthly, there are specific protections in the Bill for the economic position of the Chagos Islands, security arrangements, and measures to protect the natural environment and biodiversity, along with a range of steps in Clauses 5 and 6 that the Government will have to bring forward. That package of measures offers the best way forward for the Chagos Islands and the Chagossian people.
It is rare in politics, or in life, that we get an opportunity to start again. This is that second opportunity, and Parliament needs to grasp it. I look forward to the debate that lies ahead, and I beg to move.