Contribution
My Lords, first, I want to place on the record my thanks to everyone who has spoken to this debate, including the Minister, who was given an unenviable, if unsurprising, position. The reality is that it was not only unsurprising but almost inevitable that the Bill before us today would be, given the juxtaposition, contrasted with what has gone before by way of the previous government Bill.
I want to pick out a few points that came up in the debate. The noble Lord, Lord Lilley, is absolutely right: we would all prefer to be in a position where this was not needed in the first place. As has been highlighted by a number of speakers, we were not facing something that was going to be internationally compelling against us to hand over the islands. The exemptions in the ICJ and UNCLOS have been mentioned. Therefore, a lot of the actions taken were utterly unnecessary.
Like most, if not all, Members of this House, I have a range of opinions. I will offer some as advice to the Government—those are advisable opinions—though I would be astonished if they agreed with some of my opinions, let alone felt themselves to be bound by them.
First, we are being brought to this position by, to a degree, a false premise. Secondly, as has been mentioned by a number of speakers, some people believe, almost benignly, that our actions in handing over this territory to Mauritius are in some way inspired by some noble concept of decolonisation. I sense exactly the reverse. The approach that was previously taken with Mauritius was to treat Chagos almost as a prize that could be handed over by a medieval monarch—at the end of some war, one side gets an additional county while the other loses it—and, beyond that, to treat the Chagossian people as some form of chattel as part of that overall position. If the inspiration is to decolonise, is there anything more anti-colonial than saying, as a country that has sovereign control of a territory, that we are going to give complete self-determination to the indigenous people? To my mind, that is the definition of anti-colonialism, and ultimately it is embraced in the Bill.
Thirdly, mention has been made by the Government that there is no alternative to the route that they have taken. Actually, we are in a position where moving forward on the deal put forward by the Government may be legally questionable, as some speakers have indicated, given the binding commitment with the US Government and whether it can move forward in their absence. It is certainly unimplementable without the support of the US Government. That is the position we are in. It is time that the Government faced up to reality, stopped flogging a dead horse and pursued a positive alternative course of action. That is what is outlined in this Bill.
Fourthly—this has been alluded to only slightly—we should realise that, although this matter holds a high level of significance in the Chagos Islands, it has implications for the wider world as well. If we take the opportunity to enshrine the right of self-determination and simply hand over territory under any level of international pressure, what sort of message does that send out to other territories? For example, in recent days, we have seen yet again sabre-rattling with President Milei in Argentina as regards the Falkland Islands. If we as a country send out a signal that we are not strong on these issues and are not prepared to embrace self-determination, it is inevitable that others will misinterpret our position.
Fifthly, the noble Baroness, Lady Meyer, or perhaps the noble Lord, Lord Bellingham, raised resettlement. Again, there is a contrast between what was contained in the previous Bill and this one. In the previous Bill, there was no automatic right of resettlement. Indeed, the only opportunity for resettlement was at the grace and favour of the Mauritian Government. If you behaved yourself and made the right noises towards them, there might be some possibility of resettlement. Otherwise, however strong your links with the Chagos Islands, you would not be able to resettle. This Bill explicitly guarantees that right of resettlement on two of the main islands within the Chagos Islands. Last night, I had the opportunity, at a meeting, to converse directly via satellite link with Misley. As has been indicated, this is not simply some theoretical or moot point. There are Chagossians now back on the Chagos Islands. They have taken those steps to resettle, and it is time that we faced up to the reality of this.
I will make one other point. The Minister has spoken about a diversity of opinion within the Chagossian community. That may well be true, yet she speaks of diversity of opinion but will not allow a referendum. She speaks about discussions with them on a range of issues but will not grant them power on the most important thing: the right of self-determination. It is time that we gave the Chagossians their place. On a positive note, I was encouraged by the number of speakers who placed at the heart of this the rights of the Chagossian people themselves—that was encouraging—and the acceptance of a need for greater protection of biodiversity. That is also in the Bill.
I mentioned in my introductory remarks that this is a second chance. Whatever disagreements I have with this Government or any other, I suspect that all Governments come in with the intention and desire to do the right thing, possibly with one eye on legacy. We have a situation in which the Prime Minister, unlike the previous one, does not have his fingerprints on the previous deal. So I ask him to look at this with a fresh pair of eyes, to embrace the opportunity for that second chance and to do the right things for the Chagossian people.
It was unsurprising that, in this debate and previous ones, there was inevitably—as is the case in Parliament—a level of ping-pong between different sides on where blame lies. But one thing that struck me very much from previous debates on the Chagos Islands was a spirit and an acknowledgment around the entire Chamber that our treatment of the Chagossian people, over many decades and many Governments, has been shameful—the most shameful aspect being the forced removal in 1967. But we cannot do anything about the past. I am always slightly dubious when Governments make a performative apology for something that happened many years ago in which they were not directly involved. We cannot do anything about the past, but we can do something about the present and the future, and for the rights and needs of the Chagossian people, which do not infringe the military security of the base—let us get rid of that misunderstanding or misappropriation of the legislation and put it in context. It is time that we as a Parliament took forward a fresh approach that puts the Chagossian people first and does the right thing for them.