M

Member

Speaking in the House of Lords on 28 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

4: After Clause 3, insert the following new Clause— “Abolition of NHS England: transition plan(1) The Secretary of State must prepare and publish a transition plan in relation to the abolition of NHS England.(2) The transition plan must set out—(a) the objectives which the abolition of NHS England is intended to achieve;(b) the arrangements and timetable for transferring the functions, property, rights and liabilities of NHS England;(c) the bodies to which those functions, property, rights and liabilities are expected to be transferred;(d) the estimated gross costs associated with the abolition of NHS England and the implementation of the arrangements mentioned in paragraph (b); (e) the estimated costs of redundancies, voluntary exits, pension liabilities and other staff-related payments arising from—(i) the abolition of NHS England,(ii) the restructuring of the Department of Health and Social Care,(iii) changes affecting integrated care boards, and(iv) changes affecting commissioning support units;(f) the estimated costs associated with—(i) the transfer, retention or disposal of property,(ii) the transfer, variation or termination of contracts,(iii) the transfer of information technology, data, records and other systems,(iv) the establishment or modification of governance and accountability arrangements,(v) the recruitment and training of staff,(vi) the retention or replacement of specialist staff and expertise,(vii) consultancy and other external professional services, and(viii) any other activity required to implement the abolition;(g) the estimated recurring annual savings expected to arise from the abolition of NHS England; (h) the extent to which the savings mentioned in paragraph (g) are expected to constitute cash-releasing savings;(i) the methodology, assumptions and baseline against which the costs and savings mentioned in this subsection are to be calculated;(j) the financial year in which the total cumulative savings arising from the abolition of NHS England are expected to exceed the total cumulative costs of implementing that abolition;(k) the existing departmental, health service or other budgets from which transition costs are to be met;(l) the effect which meeting transition costs from the budgets identified under paragraph (k) is expected to have on—(i) the provision of health services,(ii) planned capital and technology expenditure,(iii) integrated care boards,(iv) workforce budgets, and(v) other departmental programmes;(m) the amount of any savings expected to be made available for the provision of front-line health services and the arrangements by which those savings are to be identified, transferred and monitored;(n) the principal clinical, financial and operational risks associated with the transition;(o) the measures to be taken to secure the continuity of services during the transition;(p) the measures to be taken to identify, retain and transfer staff with specialist knowledge or expertise;(q) the arrangements for the transfer and continued operation of nationally significant services, contracts, information systems and corporate holdings;(r) the measures by which the Secretary of State will assess whether the objectives mentioned in paragraph (a) have been achieved.(3) The estimates contained in the transition plan must distinguish between—(a) one-off transition costs,(b) recurring expenditure,(c) gross savings,(d) net savings, (e) cash-releasing savings, and(f) non-cashable efficiencies or avoided future costs.(4) The Secretary of State must arrange for the transition plan, including its financial estimates, methodology and assumptions, to be reviewed by an independent person with experience of public-sector finance, organisational restructuring or health service administration.(5) A person carrying out a review under subsection (4) must assess—(a) whether the estimates in the transition plan are reasonable,(b) whether the plan identifies the full costs of implementation,(c) whether the methodology and assumptions used to calculate costs and savings are reasonable and have been applied consistently,(d) whether the distinction between gross, net and cash-releasing savings is clear and supportable,(e) whether the expected break-even date is supported by the available evidence, and (f) whether the arrangements for managing risks and maintaining operational continuity are adequate.(6) The person carrying out the review must prepare a report setting out the conclusions of the review.(7) The Secretary of State must publish, alongside the transition plan—(a) the report prepared under subsection (6),(b) the name of the person who carried out the review,(c) a statement of that person’s relevant experience and qualifications,(d) a description of the process by which that person was appointed, and(e) a declaration of any interests which might reasonably be thought to affect that person’s independence.(8) The Secretary of State must lay the transition plan and the report prepared under subsection (6) before Parliament.(9) The Secretary of State must comply with subsections (1) to (8) before making regulations bringing section 1 or 2 into force.(10) In this section—“cash-releasing savings” means a reduction in expenditure which releases resources that may be reallocated without reducing the level or quality of services provided;“front-line health services” means services provided directly for the prevention, diagnosis or treatment of illness, or for the care of patients;“NHS England” means the National Health Service Commissioning Board.”Member’s explanatory statement This new clause would require the Secretary of State to publish an independently reviewed transition plan before commencing the abolition of NHS England.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.