E

Earl Howe (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 28 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, in moving Amendment 4, I express my appreciation to the noble Lord, Lord Kakkar, for adding his name to it. I well recognise that Members of the Committee may be taken aback by the monumental size of this amendment, but its size is, to a very real extent, its point. The main raison d’être of the Bill—indeed, its starting point—is the abolition of NHS England and the reorganisation and reallocation of its functions and responsibilities. That is as monumental a process as it is possible to imagine, involving, as it does, just about every branch of the health service, from commissioners to providers to the training of doctors. More than that, the momentous decision to abolish NHS England came largely unheralded. The report from the noble Lord, Lord Darzi, on the state of the NHS, published in 2024, stated in terms that another top-down reorganisation of the NHS was the last thing that it needed. It seemed quite clear that the noble Lord, Lord Darzi, thought there were other ways of tackling the various issues in the NHS that he had identified. Whether or not the decision to abolish was taken in haste, I am afraid that what has happened since has been a cause for criticism. The abolition was announced without any explanation given to NHS staff about what the Government were seeking to achieve, and without any provision for redundancy funding. Planning for how the new department would look took months to get off the ground. Even now, some 18 months after the decision was announced, there is still a fog of uncertainty around where a number of commissioning responsibilities are going to sit—whether they will be devolved to ICBs or transferred to the department. Some functions, especially regulation, will need to sit centrally but will require independence from ministerial control; others will need to be devolved nearer to the bodies responsible for delivering patient outcomes. There is, as yet, no clarity on the complete picture.

More from Earl Howe (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.