B

Baroness Hoey (Non-Afl)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 28 October 2026

Debate

Railways (Interoperability in Northern Ireland) (Convention on International Carriage by Rail) (Amendment) Regulations 2026

Contribution

My Lords, here we are again—another SI, another dinner hour. As many of us have warned for some time, until we actually stop allowing a foreign power, the EU, to take over making the rules for part of our own country, we will be continuing with these SIs. In welcoming the noble Lord to his place, I know his genuine interest in railways, so I imagine he will have read what is actually, I think, the largest ever statutory instrument I have seen. It is a 40-page document with 54 regulations. I know that his opposite number, the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, will also have read it with great interest. Probably both of them could actually recite the technical details in detail. But, apart from 30 minutes in a committee in the other place, this will be the only scrutiny to which this legislation will be subjected to in this Parliament. Once again, we have regulations that will introduce a divergence in law and authority between two parts of our country, and once again without this Parliament making the laws. The real significance of this strategy instrument is that, whereas today the whole of the United Kingdom is subject to the same law in relation to railways, once these regulations come into effect the country will be divided in two, with one law applying to GB and another law applying to Northern Ireland. The regulations will introduce and give effect to a law made in, as I have said, a foreign Parliament that will be imposed on part of the UK. The lack of opportunity even to debate these regulations, never mind change them, makes this absurd. It is also constitutionally an outrage that a part of this country should be reduced by laws we do not make and cannot change, and yet that is what we are doing tonight. There has been no consultation. Nowhere else do we legislate without at least the façade of consultation with the public, but when it comes to Northern Ireland, that is always null and void. Why has there been no consultation? A chat with the Department for Infrastructure, its Minister, and Translink is not consultation. What about all the businesses affected and the suppliers involved? The Government are at least being honest by saying, more or less, that there is no point in consultation. The Minister himself said there was limited scope. It would be a pointless exercise. Of course, the Minister, whether he likes these regulations or not, is obliged to implement them because of the Windsor Framework. In the other place, the Minister suggested that the debate on these regulations was not the place to raise constitutional questions of disenfranchisement, because Parliament had already voted to adopt the Windsor Framework. The Minister has not said that, but the Minister in the other place was just wrong. I remind noble Lords that we never voted specifically on the Windsor Framework, and any votes have been in relation to different aspects of it through statutory instruments, the first being on 29 March 2023 on the democratic scrutiny legislation. In this context, where is the place to address the constitutional implications of these regulations, if it is not now and in a debate such as this—if not now, when? We are told, in effect, that we have no choice. What sort of way is that for any Government to run our country—to rule that, in part of the United Kingdom, the law is being changed by some people and an institution that we have no say in? Is it something that other Members would accept for their county or area: that they cannot change the laws that are imposed and they simply have the obligation, as this SI will have, upon criminal sanction, to implement them? We are creating in these regulations a scenario in which railways will be governed in a part of the UK not by an agency of the United Kingdom but by the EU’s railway agency. When we look at Regulations 28 to 30, we discover that for a supplier in GB to supply any railway equipment to Northern Ireland, it must apply for and obtain a declaration of conformity that it is complying with the handed-down laws of a foreign Parliament. The Government, and indeed the Minister, have not even acknowledged that there will be an impact on businesses in Northern Ireland and GB. We are creating a separate railway regime for Northern Ireland, so businesses supplying equipment to Northern Ireland will have to meet the requirement laid down by the EU. This will lead to additional paperwork, declarations and costs. Will the Minister, when he is summing up, actually deny that there will be extra costs for businesses? We are seeing a drip-drip moving of Northern Ireland further away from the rest of the United Kingdom. This cannot be allowed to continue. Our railways in Northern Ireland have been safe, despite the many years of the IRA trying constantly to blow them up and block the line from Belfast to Dublin. They go through some of the most beautiful parts of Northern Ireland. I am sure the Minister would prefer to be discussing how we could have them electrified and get railway lines back to parts of Northern Ireland such as Fermanagh, where we used to have them. Instead of discussing what the public would really be interested in, we are discussing this because the Government have lost control of what happens in one part of our own country. It really is shameful. That is why, despite these regulations being technical, unless I hear something very important from Minister, I will be opposing them. They were opposed in the other place. There was a vote in the other place and more than 100 Members of Parliament voted against this statutory instrument. I am pleased that gradually more and more people are beginning to realise that the Windsor Framework is destroying businesses in Northern Ireland, those that want to work in Great Britain and those that want to go to Northern Ireland, and that we have to do something about it. I beg to move my amendment.

More from Baroness Hoey (Non-Afl)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.