Contribution
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Hoey, on securing this debate. I want to make it clear how offensive regulations of this sort are to all unionists, whether they live in Northern Ireland or Great Britain. It is offensive and unnecessary to have different laws in Northern Ireland and Great Britain, and that those laws should be imposed by a foreign power. It is offensive that there was no consultation and that Northern Ireland electors have no say in their making and cannot reject them. Moreover, it is offensive to electors in Great Britain that some aspects of the laws changed by this statutory instrument apply this side of the Irish Sea. I hope the Minister will confirm that, although he did not bother to mention in his opening speech that he was changing the laws of Great Britain.
In fact, that is the main reason the EU insisted on the Northern Ireland protocol, now rebadged as the Windsor—whatever it is. It wanted to use it and Northern Ireland as a lever to impose EU law on the whole of the UK. I recall attending a meeting at the LSE during the debates about the withdrawal process, at which the EU negotiator said that the EU is a legislative hegemon and intends to remain so. It wants, as an objective in itself, to impose its laws outside its own territory—which is not particularly necessary, but it is what it wants to do.
It is not because, as some of the nationalists and Sinn Féin say, that the objective was avoiding a border between Northern Ireland and the Republic. That was not really the objective; we can see that in these regulations, which actually create a border between Northern Ireland and the Republic. Paragraph 5.5 of the Explanatory Memorandum says:
“A change in area of use will also occur in the case of a vehicle that crosses the border on the island of Ireland”.
It goes on:
“A change of the area of use of vehicles … will trigger the need for authorisation to place on the market”.
It therefore keeps a border in Ireland, from the regulatory point of view, but imposes, as most EU stuff does, additional bureaucratic procedures. Previously authorised vehicles need to be reauthorised, if they change their area of use, and moving from Northern Ireland to southern Ireland is such a change. Even if a vehicle is intended for use only in Northern Ireland, it will still need reauthorisation. It says:
“If vehicles are intended to be used in Northern Ireland only”,
they have to be reauthorised. The only difference is that then the vehicle owner has the option of applying to the agency set up by the EU, or the Department for Infrastructure.
Ministers and noble Lords may be irritated by the stream of regulations and statutory instruments, and the debates that they trigger, generated by the Northern Ireland protocol/Windsor whatsit. They should, however, brace themselves because dynamic alignment, to which this Government are committed—the previous Chancellor in her Mais lecture said she wanted to see dynamic alignment unilaterally applied to virtually every area of trade with the EU—will require us to accept all regulations passed by the EU since we left. We know roughly how many there are because each regulation bears a number. So far this year, it has got up to regulation 2106/26—more than 2,000 have been passed this year. There have been more than 25,000 regulations introduced since we left in 2020, so your Lordships should look forward to a tsunami of statutory instruments and debates of this nature, as we try to absorb in our legislation everything that has happened since we left.
Why does it have so much legislation? It is because it is committed to it; it is what it does. It has had innumerable reports, most recently pointing out that the reason the EU is the slowest-growing continent in the world is that it is overregulated—but it cannot stop itself from doing it. It is what it does, just as drug addicts take drugs. Why we should consider joining such an organisation or unilaterally adopting its regulations and forcing on ourselves the very things that have made it the slowest-growing economy in Europe beats me. We are growing faster than the major countries in Europe thanks to Brexit—let us keep it that way.