Contribution
My Lords, another night, another statutory instrument connected to the Windsor Framework. I fully accept the many frustrations connected with the implementation of the Windsor Framework, which are widely understood in Northern Ireland.
I thank the Minister for his very clear exposition, in many ways clearer than the statutory instrument document that we have in front of us, and substantially so, and I am grateful to him for that. I also accept that the noble Baroness, Lady Hoey, is right: there is a problem in general about the Government’s mode of address and consultation on these Windsor Framework-related documents. As I say, this is not the first, and it will not be the last that we have enjoyed in this Chamber at dinner hour.
This matter of mode of address is important. Let me say one thing that is significant: I understand why it often seems that the problems associated with this legislation are so small—they are problems just for Translink, I think it says at one point. Well, we need to know more about what those problems might be for Translink. Again, the noble Baroness, Lady Hoey, is right that it is not exactly clear what the problems for business are. It may be that they are slight, but it does not matter. The point is that it is a big, politically sensitive area in Northern Ireland. That is the big thing that government has to ask. The Government’s relationship to the Windsor Framework is a problem.
Let us be clear, by the way: the Windsor Framework passed with a larger majority in the House of Commons than the Anglo-Irish agreement of 1985 by some long way and we have therefore to take it seriously, but the Windsor Framework is not simply an agency under which we have to cope with this sort of Euro legislation. It is important also because, as the Command Paper states clearly on page 5, it is an unhooking from the pressure in the earlier phases of negotiation accepted by our Governments—Tory Governments of 2017 to 2019—and documents of withdrawal; that, for example, the British Government will work to create an all-Ireland economy. That is the unhooking. It is very clear on page 5, for example, of the Command Paper that this will be a different path of development for Northern Ireland, a path of development that has been hugely successful. It is widely accepted that after the Belfast agreement, the Northern Ireland region is now the fastest growing, and Belfast is probably doing better than Manchester. Can we get away with saying that? Well, the figures look as if that is the case.
The problem has been that the Government will only come to the House and tell us, “Here is the latest irritating thing we are doing on the Windsor Framework”. The Windsor Framework is something this Government fully support, but they will not draw attention to their major area of success, the growth of Belfast. The debate then becomes so downturned, miserable and depressed. That is why I am talking about the Government’s mode of address on this subject. Just read page 5 again of the Command Paper and add to it something that it does not specifically mention: the defence expenditure of the UK in Belfast. This is the context: Northern Ireland’s economy has rarely looked stronger, and it relates to that key element in the Windsor Framework, which exists along with these myriad other irritations.
I have one final point. I said, “another night, another statutory instrument”, but actually it is not quite the same as before. We are on the eve of some form of reset between the United Kingdom and the EU—I think 20 November is the date. What this will mean, to put this very crudely—it has already been more than hinted at by the noble Lord, Lord Lilley—is that we are all going to become rule takers. In Northern Ireland specifically, let us consider what is proposed—so what one reads about regarding the SPS deal. The United Kingdom Parliament is going to be accepting rules in the same way that the Northern Ireland Assembly has had to do, with one exception, of course: it will not actually have a Stormont brake. That is what the democratically elected Government are moving towards, but the specificity of Northern Ireland’s uniqueness at the present stage, that it alone has to be a rule taker from the European Union, looks as if it is going to change quite markedly, especially when we get into next year and when we read about what an SPS agreement is likely to include.
So, in conclusion, it is not another night, another Windsor Framework statutory instrument; it is the last of an old type of debate.