L

Lord Dodds of Duncairn (DUP)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 28 October 2026

Debate

Railways (Interoperability in Northern Ireland) (Convention on International Carriage by Rail) (Amendment) Regulations 2026

Contribution

My Lords, I appreciate the opportunity to take part in this debate and congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Hoey, on securing it. It is important to continue to debate regularly laws that apply to part of the United Kingdom, especially when they are set by others and not by the House of Commons, the House of Lords or the Stormont Assembly. When they are set by people who do not live, vote or have any role in the United Kingdom, it is fair that we should examine in great detail what these laws are all about. I listened carefully to the noble Lord, Lord Bew, and I obviously have great respect for his views, but I remind him that, in terms of the narrative, the investment coming into Northern Ireland is mainly in the services area, and the services are of course outside and have nothing to do with the Windsor Framework. That is where the growth is in Northern Ireland. He said references to the all-Ireland economy were removed as a result of the Windsor Framework, but, of course, every piece of legislation under the Windsor Framework is to align Northern Ireland with the rest of the EU and the Republic of Ireland, rather than the rest of the United Kingdom. That is the fundamental problem with the Windsor Framework—which he well knows, because we have debated this many times. On this SI, I ask the Minister to address the point that was raised by the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee. The Government said that the 2016 directive, which would be implemented by these regulations, “already applies in NI as international law by consequence of the Windsor Framework’s ratification”. The Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee, in paragraph 81 of its report, was scathing about the Government’s responses, saying that this was completely untrue. I wonder whether the Government will take the opportunity tonight to deal with that assertion by the committee that this is “incorrect”. What we have been asked to scrutinise is a done deal. We do not have the opportunity in either House of this Parliament, or elsewhere, such as in Stormont, to change what is before us. It has already been decided by others and imposed upon us. It is striking that in their answers to the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee, the Government set out how extensive the discussions had to be with the European Commission to reach a consensus and to engage closely with it on the legal drafting and timelines for implementation. There was no such consultation, close detailed negotiations or discussions with anyone in Northern Ireland. The noble Lord, Lord Bew, is right to raise once again the issue of public consultation. The Government said in their response to the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee that “the scope for policy discretion in how the Directive is reflected in domestic law is limited”. That is an understatement if ever there was one. That is why they did not consult with anyone other than the Department for Infrastructure and Translink. These are serious matters. Every time we examine these regulations and SIs, we come back to the fundamental themes: laws being imposed upon us; the lack of any proper, convincing consultation with those affected by it; and divergence between Great Britain and Northern Ireland. I would like the Minister to explain whether he sees any risk to the supply chain for industries in this area in Northern Ireland. I note that in their response to the scrutiny committee, the Government said that they “have no active plans to implement the content of the 2016 Directive in Great Britain”. They have spent enormous amounts of time negotiating with the EU about imposing it on a part of the United Kingdom. Can the Minister tell us: if it is good for Northern Ireland why is it not being considered for the rest of the United Kingdom? Having done all this work, it would be simple to transpose it to rest of the United Kingdom as well. What is the reason for not doing that? Finally, can the Minister set out in detail the consultation arrangements with the Northern Ireland Department for Infrastructure to ensure that there is not a lot of divergence? The Government said that these arrangements were “effective during the first major revision of Britain’s National Technical Specification Notices for rail interoperability”. I would like to know: who is engaged in those arrangements; what is the accountability mechanism; and how do Northern Ireland Assembly Members interact with them? I thank the Minister for introducing these regulations but if the noble Baroness, Lady Hoey, pushes for a vote, we will certainly be in the Lobby with her.

More from Lord Dodds of Duncairn (DUP)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.