Contribution
My Lords, I thank the Minister and her officials for their detailed and extremely helpful engagement between Committee and Report. I apologise to the House, as I have been rather greedy in tabling 25 amendments in this group, but I promise that I will try to explain them as briefly as I can. The amendments in my name and those of my noble friend Lord Holmes and the noble Baroness, Lady Kidron, are in three subgroups, to which the Minister alluded. I will briefly go through them.
The first group, which includes Amendments 7, 9, 10, 11 and 18 to 25, would strengthen the staged reporting requirements on the three different groups of regulated entities set out in the Bill. These amendments would require regulated entities to produce a final report 28 days after they first reported an incident to their relevant regulator. My experience of going through a cyber attack—sadly, it is real, lived experience—is that, for the first 72 hours, you do not know what has happened. If you really want to learn what happened in a cyber attack, you have to let the dust settle a bit to know who attacked you, what data was accessed and what was going on with the systems. Therefore, in addition to the 24-hour and 72-hour reporting requirements, it would be much more sensible to have a 28-day final report. That would be completely consistent with the NIS2 directive, and it is just common sense.
In Committee, the Minister said that she did not think it was necessary to put this in the Bill because regulators could choose to request a report from a regulated entity. Again, in my experience, that is the worst of all possible worlds. When you are in the midst of a cyber attack, the last thing you need is people making up the rules as they go along. The more certainty you can have on what the reporting requirements are from each of the different regulators that you will undoubtedly have to report to—it will be more than one—the more that the limited cognitive capacity which everybody has in a cyber attack can be focused on fixing the problem.
Therefore, while you want to retain the ability for regulators to intervene during this 28-day period, having a firm, final report stage will give real certainty to the regulated entities and the regulators themselves that this is a regime that will aim to learn and share that learning as, I am afraid, we have more and more of these incidents. I ask the Minister to reconsider the view that she set out in Committee, because my amendments in this subgroup would both help victims of cyber attacks—those regulated entities trying to grapple with the fog of these attacks—and ensure genuine, proper learning from the incidents.
The second group of 12 amendments I have in this group concerns the reporting to customers, as the Minister has just addressed. Amendments 26 to 29, 31 to 34 and 36 to 39 require regular reporting to customers. The Minister has tabled similar amendments: Amendments 30, 35 and 40. The only difference, to which she has just alluded, is that in my amendments the regulated organisations would be required to advise on any measures or remedies that customers are able to take. I would hope that good service providers are trying to help their customers when their customers are caught up in a cyber attack, but I accept the Minister’s argument that they might not always have the appropriate skills to give good advice. As such, I thank her very much for her constructive engagement. I will, when the process allows, not move my amendment in favour of the Government’s one in this group.
My final amendment in this group is Amendment 42, to which the noble Lord, Lord Clement-Jones, the noble Baroness, Lady Kidron, and my noble friend Lord Holmes have added their names. This amendment would allow regulated persons to report incidents, cyber threats and near misses voluntarily, either to the NCSC or their regulators—again, in line with Article 30 of the NIS2 directive. This reporting would not increase their liability or impose any new obligations on them.
Again, I welcome the constructive discussions that I have had with the Minister and her officials on this, and I welcome her statement at the Dispatch Box as she introduced this group. I ask her, when she sums up, to confirm why the Government do not need to put this in the Bill, when a voluntary scheme will be developed and how she intends to consult on it. I am sure that she will have good answers to those questions. I repeat my grateful thanks for the positive collaboration in this group.