B

Baroness Neville-Jones (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 26 October 2026

Debate

Cyber Security and Resilience (Network and Information Systems) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, Amendment 16 in my name is also concerned with reporting. Reporting, I think the Government agree, is a general proposition, and getting it right lies at the absolute core of a successful cyber security and resilience regime. In our work on the Bill, we have been able to agree on what constitutes the trigger for reporting. Like many other colleagues, I thank the Minister for the way in which she reacted to the comments made by colleagues and the amendments that she has made to make the system more operational and to reduce the liability of having unnecessary reporting of a kind which overloads the system without increasing the level of security that it brings. Where we have not yet succeeded in entirely agreeing, I think, is on the question of the factors which operators should take into account when they are making their report. Operators not located in data centres have, in fact, been given guidance; they know what they need to put in their reports and what they need to cover. But for data centres, the Bill contains no guidance at all on the relevant factors. While the Government have said, and I believe them, that they wish to increase the consistency of treatment between operators—that is to say, in different locations—it is odd that operators in data centres which we hope people are going to want to occupy are the people who are left in the dark about their duties. If you look at the numbers, operators of essential services in locations other than data centres have seven factors that have been identified as necessary for reporting, and the Government have recently added a further two without feeling the need for consultation. The relevant digital service providers have seven factors, and many service providers which hitherto have not been regulated now have seven factors to take into account. So one can see—which I think is perfectly sensible—that a list of topics and aspects that must be reported on is very clearly set out, except for those who operate in data centres, who are left in the dark. They are left in the dark as to what the trigger, “significant impact”, is meant to mean. That is what they have to focus on. They do not know what the regulators would identify as constituting “significant impact”. The great advantage, obviously, of factor lists being in the Bill is that it gives operators time to prepare for the regulatory regime before it comes into effect. Knowing the definition of “significant” is absolutely key to being able to make a proper report. So my amendment inserts into the Bill 10 factors that data centres’ operators should have regard to. They are drawn from the Bill’s own definition of the functions of a data centre, and they have been developed with techUK, which represents over 90% of data centre operators in the United Kingdom. These thresholds will still be set up and done through secondary legislation for data centres, on the same basis as other categories. But without the factor list, the data centres will be the last to get going with preparations, and the security the Bill is designed to deliver, and which we all want, will arrive later, too. Given the high penalties involved in failure to report properly, £17 million or 4% of turnover, legislative differentiation between data centre operators and the rest could have an unintended—and, I am concerned, unwanted—discriminatory element. So I hope the Minister can accommodate the notion of bringing the factors into the Bill, and I look forward to her reply.

More from Baroness Neville-Jones (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.