V

Viscount Camrose (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 26 October 2026

Debate

Cyber Security and Resilience (Network and Information Systems) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I thank the Minister for introducing this group of amendments. I am grateful for the concessions that the Government have made on the definition of an incident, following my noble friend Lady Neville-Jones’s amendments in Committee. However, I will press on the point that my noble friend made on her Amendment 16. The Government have expanded the number of factors determining whether an incident involving essential services is “significant” and widened the reporting requirements for data centres, without outlining a similar list of factors for them. Surely, if consistency between data centres and other regulated services is the goal, widening the discrepancy in the lists of factors constituting significance must be counterintuitive. I hope the Minister will be able to consider my noble friend’s Amendment 16, at least in light of the need for consistency for all those affected by the Bill. I am also grateful to my noble friend Lady Harding of Winscombe for retabling her amendments to the reporting regime. She has raised a number of important points that we should take very seriously. As far as I know, she is the only one among us today who has led a sufficiently large organisation to be impacted by this through a serious cyber attack. I and everybody else must take extremely seriously the input she has set out not just here today but in her very good opinion piece in this morning’s Financial Times, which I commend to noble Lords. I hope that the Government will, at the very least, keep her suggestions under review. Amendment 86, in my name and those of my noble friends Lord Markham and Lord Holmes, is a slightly reworked amendment from Committee. It would require not only a consultation into amnesty-based reporting but confidential reporting. A great many ransomware attacks go unreported because victims choose to avoid public knowledge. This hinders our efforts to protect others against falling victim to the same attack. Governments must strike the right balance between encouraging reporting of these attacks and penalising those who do not adhere to their security duties. I understand that a poorly designed amnesty risks letting off the hook those who should be penalised, but I am also aware that the threat of either a penalty or merely public knowledge of a breach often works to deter reporting. We think it is well worth conducting a consultation into this balance in order to collect appropriate data about these serious events in a way that does not prejudice the outcomes for any victims of these attacks. I hope the Minister will urge her officials to carry on considering this and to come back with proposals in future.

More from Viscount Camrose (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.