Contribution
I thank noble Lords for their amendments tabled in this group and their continuing positive intentions within our discussion. It is clear that we all share the same objective: a functional and proportionate regime that balances timely and relevant information for regulators, the NCSC and customers, without placing undue burden on business.
I will start with the amendments tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Harding, which seek to add an additional reporting requirement at 28 days. I am grateful to the noble Baroness for the discussion we have had on this point and appreciate the constructive spirit in which these amendments have been tabled. However, I still do not think that a further stage of mandatory reporting is needed to ensure that regulators and the NCSC have the necessary information. In our view, the Bill’s existing provisions already strike the right balance in this regard. The two-stage reporting model ensures that regulators and the NCSC have sufficient information to start assessing what has occurred, what support may be needed and what wider risks may be posed, without imposing additional blanket reporting obligations on all entities.
I agree that learning lessons from incidents is crucial for resilience. However, I am not persuaded that a mandatory 28-day report is the right mechanism, noting that regulators can request more information when they need it. Effective resilience works best when organisations engage openly and constructively with regulators throughout recovery. Given the variation in cyber incidents, a fixed reporting requirement risks prioritising compliance over meaningful engagement and may not produce information of sufficient value to justify the additional burden. This approach supports a collaborative relationship between industry, regulators and the NCSC, focused on recovery and resilience outcomes.
The amendment in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Neville-Jones, would add a list of factors for data centre operators to consider when determining whether an incident is significant. I agree that proportionate and workable factors will be important for the sector. Data centres are one of our newest designated CNI sectors. They have rapidly become a fundamental part of the infrastructure underpinning our economy, while our understanding of this infrastructure and how best to regulate it is still developing.
This makes consultation particularly important. I have committed to giving industry, academics, technical experts and Ofcom the opportunity to inform the development of these factors, drawing on their operational expertise. We will draw from the proposals in Amendment 16, and the noble Baroness will see these factors reflected in the consultation, but it is right that we do not pre-empt a full, open consultation. Operators will have an appropriate period to prepare for the new requirements before they take effect, ensuring they have time to understand and adjust to the final framework.
On the amendment in the name of the noble Viscount, Lord Camrose, regarding a consultation on amnesty-based reporting for ransomware, I thank him for our discussions since Committee on the amendment. However, I am still not persuaded that there is a case for consulting on a protected route for ransomware reporting. On the contrary, regulators must be able to access ransomware reports if they are to assess whether organisations have taken the necessary steps to secure their systems. This is particularly important in the context of the NIS regulations, which have been put in place to ensure the security and resilience of the UK’s most essential services. If NIS regulators are denied the ability to scrutinise how ransomware attacks have succeeded in compromising these services, there is a risk that the regulatory framework will not work as intended. In saying this, I am not rejecting the idea that safe harbours can play a role in facilitating some types of reporting. I have already said that the Government will examine the role that legal protections may play in voluntary reporting, but I cannot endorse the noble Viscount’s proposals given the challenges they would create for existing regulatory regimes.
The noble Baroness, Lady Harding, posed a question on the next steps for the voluntary scheme. Significant work is required to design a voluntary reporting regime that can meaningfully deliver engagement, avoid duplication with existing reporting routes and secure industry participation. We therefore intend to undertake further work on the design of the regime.
The mandatory obligations in the Bill apply to entities within the regulatory scope. The primary purpose of the voluntary regime would be to increase the reporting of cyber near-misses by regulated entities. However, this would not automatically preclude participation by other organisations, and there may be value in receiving information from other organisations outside the regulatory parameters, particularly where this can contribute to wider cyber resilience. So, we will take that consultation forward in due course as part of the implementation of the Bill.
Finally, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Clement-Jones, for his amendment and agree with the principle that visibility and transparency of the reporting regime are important. Parliament, regulators and the public should have confidence that the regime is operating well. However, I am not persuaded that placing a statutory duty in the Bill to publish incident volumes is the right approach. The Bill already provides mechanisms through which the Government and regulators can provide oversight and transparency on the operation of the regime. In particular, and subject to consultation, I expect the statement of strategic priorities and wider engagement with regulators will provide opportunities to share insights on how incident reporting obligations are implemented in practice. For this reason, while I support the objective of transparency, I do not consider that prescribing these reporting requirements in the Bill is the most appropriate or proportionate approach.
Once again, I thank noble Lords for their collaborative approach. Their scrutiny and expertise have been hugely valuable and have resulted in the amendments in this group tabled in my name, which I agree have improved the Bill.