Contribution
My Lords, I am grateful to the noble Lord for securing this timely debate, though I confess I speak with some trepidation given the considerable expertise in this Chamber. But as a refugee who arrived in this country from Iran as a young girl because of political violence and religious persecution, and as someone who has stayed abreast of developments in Iran and across the wider Middle East, this is a subject close to my heart.
I have spoken previously on why I think the joint US-Israel attack on Iran in February was an act of strategic folly, the consequences of which we continue to live with. The prospect of a renewed assault on Iran, soon after the mid-term elections in America and the recent elections in Israel, fills me with dread and illustrates all too well that our collective ability to mediate and prevent conflict is diminishing.
Although our assessments of the 1945 global order as broken, bruised or in the process of being bolstered may diverge, surely those who care about human flourishing and the conditions that support it cannot be content with the current era of disorder and unpeace. From a faith perspective, I certainly find this state of affairs deeply troubling. The apostle Paul wrote in 1 Corinthians, chapter 14, verse 33, that God is not a God of disorder, tumult or dissension but of peace, order, harmony and shalom.
Some will argue that, if you want peace, you must prepare for war. That logic is evident in last year’s strategic defence review and in subsequent conversations about how we fund Britain’s military commitments. I do not deny the utility of military deterrence, and I am immensely grateful and indebted to our Armed Forces, who risk danger to protect us. At the same time, I fear that the practice of some countries in recent years suggests we are now moving towards a new formulation altogether—namely, that if you want peace, you must first wage war.
That is a dangerous path to tread. It invites a new global arms race, renewed wars of conquest, shrinking trade and prosperity, and the collapse of the co-operation needed to confront shared global threats. It is a dystopian path that threatens our God-given human dignity and the very integrity of God’s creation. I worry that the preparation for war and the act of war itself become our principal ways of imagining the road to peace. We need instead, as the Lutheran archbishop of Estonia has suggested, to take an alternative pathway—namely, if you want peace, prepare for peace and invest in the instruments necessary to uphold it.
The 2025 strategic defence review was necessary, but where is the strategic peacebuilding review to complement it? At a time of heightened insecurity, we need a focused assessment of whether the UK has the policies, institutions, capabilities and partnerships needed to prevent violent conflict and strengthen the conditions for sustainable peace. At a time when considerable attention is rightly being given to defence, deterrence and national resilience, we also need to examine the other side of the security equation: how Britain prevents conflict, addresses the conditions in which violence and instability develop, and strengthens social cohesion and supports peace before, during and after crises. A strategic peacekeeping review could bring together the domestic and international dimensions of peacebuilding and consider the contribution of government, civil society, faith communities, business and international partners.
None of this is to belittle steps that have been taken in recent years. The creation of a 16-person peace process and mediation team at the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office is a welcome step, but how might this capability be strengthened and embedded across government, rather than remaining primarily as an FCDO-led operational function? Rather than undertaking such a strategic peace review and investing in peacebuilding mechanisms, we seem intent on financing our rearmament by salami-slicing the development budget and, in so doing, diminishing our ability to tackle the drivers of conflict in many parts of the world. This is a false economy and feels self-defeating. Instead, we should invest in peacebuilding, with fresh funding and a more joined-up national conversation than we have had to date.
This is an agenda that the Church takes seriously. The commitment to peacebuilding is part of our very DNA. We are willing to work together with government and others in creating the conditions in which war and conflict no longer feel like the logical choice or the inevitable outcome. Only last year, the Church of England Pensions Board established the Global Centre for Peacebuilding and Business to respond to the growing global demand for minerals and energy; the expansion of extractive industries into fragile and conflict-affected contexts; the risks that flow from this; and the extraordinary presence and reach of the Church in many of those places.
In South Sudan, a country where, for ordinary people, the situation is getting worse and nothing seems to be getting through to the political inner circle, the Church continues to be the most trusted and far-reaching national institution, engaged in peacebuilding, humanitarian responses, education and healthcare. This role is replicated in other fragile and conflict-ridden countries and underscores the Church’s commitment to being a force for reconciliation and peace.
All this is by way of saying that, in today’s age of disorder, peacebuilding should be understood not merely as a humanitarian endeavour but as a strategic imperative to national security, economic resilience and long-term stability. In a world increasingly focused on preparing for conflict, it is important that we continue making the case for peace and peacebuilding with all due seriousness. Committing to a strategic peace review, to sit alongside the strategic defence review, would be an important but long-overdue step in this direction.