Contribution
My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the right reverend Prelate, who brings unique experience to this conversation. I point her in the direction of the emerging markets and developing economies taskforce that the Church of England pension trustees are participating in. If successful, that project will achieve and deliver investment at a far greater scale than any development assistance from any country ever could and will unlock the real gains that are needed in developing countries, which will see more stability. That relates directly to the topic of today’s debate.
I am very grateful to my noble friend Lord McConnell for securing this debate. Occasions such as these often allow this Chamber to be at its best. So far, the contributions this afternoon have proved that to be the case.
The noble Lord, Lord Anderson, referred to Inter-Mediate. I thank him for the work that he has led with it alongside Jonathan Powell. They have done tremendous work, almost all of it invisible by necessity. I have had some involvement with some of its work at various points along the way, and I have had some amazing advice from Jonathan about the necessity of patience, discretion and building trust. In today’s world of what is too often reactive diplomacy, where everything needs to be said publicly and responded to instantly, the work that Inter-Mediate does just proves what can be achieved by taking a slightly different approach.
Last night, I had the pleasure of attending an event here to mark 10 years since the signing of the peace agreement in Colombia. Former President Santos spoke about the painstaking work, the political risk, the essential role of the international community, and the commitment that is needed to this day to protect and secure that agreement.
When asked how the UK had helped, former President Santos said, “The most significant change happened when we instructed the Colombian armed forces to stop killing the FARC”. President Santos explained that, when the army began to capture fighters to demobilise and reintegrate them into society, the armed forces were no longer seen as devils by the fighters. He said that real progress was achieved when the enemy became viewed as people, not to be destroyed but rather to be defeated, because you need them to negotiate with in order to bring about a stable peace.
There are obviously lessons that can be learned from the Colombian experience, just as there are from other fragile and all-too-rare lasting peace agreements, such as the Good Friday agreement and Dayton, which are incredibly fragile and which we must protect at every opportunity. But there is a warning about trying to learn lessons and apply them directly in different contexts. It is tempting to search for a template—a set of principles to deploy that will guarantee success in other contexts—but, as we all know, each conflict is unique. The motivations, relationships, history and political space, the involvement of neighbouring states, which we see more and more, the approach of more distant but powerful nations, the presence of hard power, the deployment of technology and the character of the protagonists are all different.
Instead of the hard work of innovation—coming up with creative new approaches, combining our defence, diplomacy and development work, working alongside the multilateral development banks and multilateral systems—too often I see the international community’s response is to look to the tools that it used last time to ask itself which of those it ought to deploy. This is fine, important and can lead to some success—UN resolutions, increasingly outraged statements of condemnation, which I have given myself, sanctions, demands for accountability, side meetings and symbolism. These are all important and have their place, but issues and places are too often picked up and put down by the multilateral system and by nations. Look at Haiti, and even Sudan. There are so many examples. Who is holding it close? Who is really taking responsibility for what is happening and saying, “We’re the penholder: we have the job of making this better, however long it takes”. In an era when countries can trade off their relationships, not just with their neighbours, but with the US, China, Russia and Europe, protagonists can and do ignore the standard toolkit responses.
When agreements work, they are the result of deep understanding and, often, local leadership. This is especially true in Africa, where one year since the fall of El Fasher we continue to see widespread massacres and atrocities. While high-intensity wars in Ukraine and Gaza generate so much news, attention and, it is true, a massive share of the casualties, it is Sudan and, indeed, Africa as a whole that is the deadliest continent for deliberate non-combat violence, directed deliberately and specifically at civilians, with women paying a particularly high price. We see non-state armed groups, private armies, Russian mercenaries, extremist terrorist groups, weak states and communities desperately trying to survive despite it all.
This debate is about what the UK can and should do. If the UK and our partners want to help, as I believe we do, we must supplement the statement making with statecraft. We, by which I mean the international community, need less reliance on shaky deals between warlords and more time given to building long-term, resilient, civilian relationships that form the foundation of any lasting peace. We saw Kagame and Tshisekedi summoned by the White House to sign a deal. That did not bring about peace to eastern DRC, which is now ravaged by Ebola and lacks the community trust or state apparatus to do what is needed.
Last night, when I asked President Santos what his experience told him would help in Sudan, he gave an answer that I agree with completely. He said that the UK should give its time and attention to the supporters of the warring parties in neighbouring countries and further afield and that we should work hard to support civil society and local civilian leadership. It is low-key, unglamorous and time-consuming, but it is vital. Trade, transactional approaches and saying that we will bestow or withdraw development assistance or other such gestures will always fail. They have always failed. There is no example of where that approach, so often advocated for, has succeeded.
The UK, as others have said, has credibility in building and sustaining peace alongside others, notably Qatar and Norway. We must use this well and do so urgently, especially in places where the ordinariness of earning a living, raising your children and seeing out your days in peace is far too often denied. It should never ever be taken for granted.