Contribution
My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord McConnell of Glenscorrodale, for initiating this important debate and all noble Lords for their contributions.
Throughout the debate, a number of points appealed to me and struck a chord. Funnily enough, it was noble the Baroness, Lady Chapman, who talked about trust and her predecessor, my noble friend Lord Ahmad, who talked about relationships. We are talking about smart power, regional ownership, local peacebuilders and the importance of moving quickly on mediation when conflict occurs. However, none of this will proceed unless there is the political will for it to succeed. This debate has looked at how the contributions from different sectors can push more mediation and prevention of global conflict.
We live in an increasingly dangerous world. It has been said many times in this debate, but in a debate such as this it is right that we reflect on the conflicts that we are seeing all over the world, as noble Lords have, whether in Sudan, the Holy Land, Ukraine, Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Iran, Myanmar, Pakistan, Afghanistan or the Philippines. It seems almost that wherever we look there is conflict, as many noble Lords, including the noble Lord, Lord McConnell, and my noble friend Lord Bates have said: 2025 saw 65 active state-based conflicts across 35 countries, the highest number recorded since 1946. There are many more places in the world today in tension to an extent that threatens conflict. The appalling scenes in Ceuta earlier this year showed the threat that illegal migration poses to countries across the world. In France, internal disorder has seen the mass destruction of livelihoods and public buildings. Every one of us wants to see order and peace in every part of the world. His Majesty’s Government should continue to use all the diplomatic tools available to work towards that goal.
The noble Lord, Lord McConnell, has highlighted the importance of mediation in his Motion today, and we are particularly well placed as a nation to support mediation. We are a nation that respects the rule of law and is known the world over for our respect for fairness and, as other noble Lords have said, for our Diplomatic Service. But Britain today does not have the global reach it once had, and we must reflect on that. Can the Minister, when he replies to this debate, comment on the reality of Britain’s role in our increasingly unstable world and say what specific steps his department is taking to promote peace and an end to conflict across the world? In particular, can he say what work his department is doing towards a stable and long-lasting two-state solution in Israel and Palestine?
As a member state, Britain supports the work of the United Nations in promoting peace and stability through its Peacebuilding Commission, the Peacebuilding Fund and the Peacebuilding and Peace Support Office. I understand that this structure has recently been reviewed. Can the Minister say whether the United Kingdom fed into that review process and, if yes, what submissions did we make? I would also be grateful if the Minister could comment on the broader challenges faced by the UN, not least as a result of the fact that Russia, a permanent member of the Security Council, is pursuing an illegal war in Ukraine, and what His Majesty’s Government’s position is on that.
The UK has contributed £630 million per year in funding for the UN for the last decade. Can Minister say whether the Government intend to continue that level of contribution or increase it? Further to that, can he say what work his department is doing to ensure that funding is going to the right places? We have all followed with interest the controversy surrounding the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East. Can Minister update the House on the Government’s assessment of the situation at UNRWA? But mediation after conflict has begun is not enough. Constant engagement, rebuilding and trade across cultural divides has an important role to play. Can the Minister say what work Ministers are doing to promote constructive engagement between nations in conflict areas across the world?
The harsh truth is that, when conflict occurs, there is often a call for more direct intervention. Peace cannot always be achieved through mediation and international co-operation alone. We saw that in Sierra Leone, where a total of nearly 4,500 British personnel were deployed in-country. We must not forget that five dedicated British military personnel lost their lives in that conflict. We saw it again in the Balkans, where tens of thousands of British troops served as part of the NATO-led peacekeeping mission. A total of 72 British Armed Forces personnel have died as a result of those operations in the Balkans, including in Bosnia, Croatia, Macedonia, Kosovo and Serbia, since 1992. We should remember their service too.
Diplomacy is essential but, without hard power, as mentioned by other noble Lords, Britain cannot play a full role alongside our international allies and partners. That is why defence spending is so important and why it was disappointing to hear the Chancellor of the Exchequer fail yesterday to set out a clear plan to hit the 3% of GDP spending target on defence. The Budget was in many ways an exercise in avoiding the tough decisions that we expect Ministers to tackle, and that was true on defence. Not only are we still waiting for the 3% spending plan, but the Chancellor has been accused of stealth cuts to the defence budget by diverting pensions savings to the Treasury rather than the defence budget.
The situation we are in on defence spending sends the wrong message to our allies, and it is important to get that message right. Overall, this debate has been really informative. It has given much food for thought and I look forward to the Minister’s response.