L

Lord Bruce of Bennachie (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 29 October 2026

Debate

Mediation, Conflict Prevention and Peacebuilding

Contribution

My Lords, I join all other noble Lords in congratulating the noble Lord, Lord McConnell, on initiating this debate and on the way he introduced it. We have had a pretty wide-ranging debate, with lots of different perspective brought into play, which is as it should be and is extremely valuable. The noble Lord, Lord McConnell, said that the problem with the Government is that they have tended to step back rather than step up. I am glad that he went on to say that there were some more positive things, and I think we should relate to that. However, it seems to me that the conversation we have is less about peacekeeping at the moment and more about conflict resolution, because until you resolve a conflict it is very difficult to keep the peace, and things have been moving in a pretty bad direction. However, this debate has been extremely instructive. The comments of the noble Lord, Lord Anderson, about his role as an intermediary were fascinating. He made it absolutely clear, as many other speakers have, that quiet engagement below the headlines can often make the difference, and he cited some really interesting examples. The work that has been done there is extremely valuable and not to be overlooked, and I am glad that he brought that to the debate. It was also pointed out that peacekeeping and conflict prevention represent value for money, but, unfortunately, we are not actually providing the money at the moment. The right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Chelmsford touched on a very powerful point. She said that the concept at the moment seems to be that you have to wage war to secure peace. That is increasingly the way some of the conflicts look, and it is extremely difficult to know how you can pull them back to say, “Actually, no, you have to fight for peace”. That was an interesting analogy because, as I will come on to say, one of the problems we have is that too many of the protagonists are not interested in peace. The noble Baroness, Lady Chapman, quite rightly said that we should not just reach for the same old toolkit, useful as it may be; we have to recognise that, in a changing world, we are going to have to find different ways of doing things. Increasingly, also, it is not just about states but non-state actors, and sometimes we have to invest in the long term. I was cited by the noble Lord, Lord Campbell-Savours, whose intervention was not unexpected. I do not wish to discredit his own genuine view, which is not widely shared but which he has come to on his own basis—I am not suggesting that he is an agent for anybody else—but the reason I raised the Budapest memorandum is that he is looking for a solution which will require the same guarantors who have not honoured the original memorandum. It is difficult, therefore, to see how you can get a settlement that can be trusted, which is really the problem we face. I want to pick up in particular what the noble Lords, Lord Hastings and Lord Bates, said. We have to engage with people we do not like, we have to take the criticisms as to why we are talking to them, and we have to do it both publicly and privately, and extensively, and be more objective. Those are powerful arguments, and all the best peace outcomes have always had that characteristic to make them happen. As the noble Lord, Lord McConnell, said in his opening remarks, conflicts have proliferated to the extent that we currently have the highest level and number of conflicts since the Second World War. The worst ones, with none showing any capacity for peace interventions, are clearly Sudan, the Middle East and Gaza and Ukraine. I am afraid that, as the noble Lord, Lord Howell, said, the UN’s current weakness is revealed for all to see. Much of this is exacerbated by the disengagement of the main players on whom the UN depends: notably, Russia, the US and, to a lesser extent, China. The UK, which supports peacekeeping and conflict prevention and resolution, has actually cut its funding to peace initiatives. I just checked the figures for the integrated security fund: for the current year, there is £854 million; next year, £545 million; the following year, £499 million; and the year after that, £471 million. That is the Government’s financial commitment to peacekeeping declining. It is not all about money—I accept that—but it is, I suggest, a movement in the wrong direction. Turning to some of the conflicts, in Sudan I find it slightly extraordinary that, with Saudi Arabia supporting the Sudanese Armed Forces and the UAE supporting the Rapid Support Forces, they are also half of the mediating quad, which also includes Egypt and the United States. It is difficult to see progress or even the capacity to prevent the most appalling atrocities and humanitarian abuses when the mediators are also protagonists in the process. The UK is the penholder, so one question to the Minister is: to what extent can we exert some pressure? We had an earlier Question about aerial bombardment in Sudan, which has been perpetrated as extensions of two of the outside players. What can the Government do to put pressure on those two players to stop these atrocities and to pay a price if they do not, as my noble friend Lord Purvis called for in the earlier Question? In the Middle East, we have not yet had the results of the Israeli elections, but Prime Minister Netanyahu has escalated assaults in the West Bank and Gaza, and he has been actively encouraged to do so by the White House—although I am not quite sure who is encouraging whom—when President Trump described him as a warrior Prime Minister, which is supposed to be a compliment. We are talking about peace, and he praises a warrior Prime Minister. Both sides in the Middle East are now promoting single-state solutions, turning their backs on the two-state solution, which is the only thing that offers long-term peace and stability. We still must not abandon our aspiration to get there, however difficult it may be. Tony Blair commented of the Belfast agreement, when he was made envoy for the quartet, that it was ironic that there was no agreed long-term solution to the division of Ireland, but peace had been secured, whereas there was an agreed and viable long-term solution to Middle East peace, but there was no peace. In the midst of this current situation, Trump and Netanyahu have started a war that they do not know how to end. On Ukraine, we have equivocal support, not from us, but from the United States—or from the White House; I see the difference—and pressure to end the war by surrendering. It is no longer just equivocal support; it has now switched to outright support for Putin’s Russia, with Trump’s envoy, Witkoff, describing Putin as humanitarian for releasing one US prisoner. That might be welcome, but he was ignoring the daily slaughter of Ukrainian civilians by Russian drones and missiles, aggravated by the United States’ degrading of Ukraine’s defence capability. It difficult to see how we can get out of these situations while the main players are behaving in this way. It must almost be observed that they do not want peace. They just want their side to win at all costs. How on earth are we supposed to respond to this? We must of course support the United Nations and initiatives that may fly. However, when President Trump seriously nominates Viktor Orbán as the candidate to be Secretary-General of the United Nations, it is obvious that, for the time being, we must look to other ways of promoting peace. The conflicts that I have referred to are promoted by misogynistic leaders with the characteristics of bullies and cowards. The UN recognised in the year 2000 with Resolution 1325 that lasting peace required the active participation of women. Yet, precisely because so many of these conflicts are about power and control by men, they are still too often ignored—while mobilising humanitarian relief and exposing abuse is all that we are left with. Yet women played a key role in the Northern Ireland peace process and are conspicuous in the fight for Ukraine’s survival. We have been talking about the United Nations and the international community. What is the role of the UK? We need a reset, a SWOTs analysis, to see what our strengths are and to deliver them on a priority basis. I ask the Minister whether that could be considered.

More from Lord Bruce of Bennachie (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.