L

Lord Bruce of Bennachie (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 10 November 2026

Debate

International Claims Commission for Ukraine (Immunities and Privileges) Order 2026

Contribution

My Lords, I thank the Minister for this introduction. We debated this in June. This is the next step in its implementation, and I think it is welcome on all sides. As the Minister said, this is an instrument of the Council of Europe, and I have just a few questions for him. This obviously takes us further down the road. Has the commission started work or when is it likely to start work? It is understood and accepted that there are no plans to visit the UK and that whatever plans might happen in the future are limited, but presumably there is the possibility that members of the commission may wish to interview Ukrainian exiles in the UK in order to get evidence for assessing damages. It would be interesting if the Minister could clarify whether that would be the case. Certainly, one would not want to obstruct such a process. We are debating this against the backdrop of current meetings between Russia and the United States, which, to be honest, are quite concerning. What it seems is being discussed comes pretty close to something like persuading the Ukrainians to surrender, which I know is not the UK’s policy. Apart from a few fringe people in the political arena, all the official parties are strongly supportive of Ukraine. Can I test the Minister a little? I know it is hypothetical, so I have no doubt that he will use that as a defence. President Zelensky has said that he is worried that we may be facing a new Yalta: a situation where the great powers carved up Europe without much reference to the people who were directly affected by it. That is obviously President Zelensky’s concern. People can recognise that the brave people of Ukraine are war-weary and exhausted and would welcome peace, but not peace at any price. Are we involved in these negotiations, and to what extent does Britain have the opportunity to influence the outcome and ensure that the interests of Ukraine and, indeed, the wider interests of Europe, are fully appreciated? One of the concerns that many of us have is that there is a degree of ignorance and carelessness within the American Administration and, indeed, America’s wider political society, in regarding Europe as some faraway place that does not affect them very much. It affects us very much, and it is not acceptable that it should be carved up by outsiders who are not party to this. I hope that the Minister will understand the concerns we have. On the specifics of the commission, I remember from the last debate that the seized Russian assets added up to about half the assessed damages or liabilities at that time. Is that still the case? Can we be sure that this is the best case for ensuring that those assets are not returned to Russia but are instead used for these purposes, and that the other half is still an obligation on Russian when it comes to the time of reconstruction? On a very minor but important detail, on the fact that the commission does not allow road traffic offences to be given immunity, we realise from past experience that this is important. We have had concerning misuses of immunity in the past, so I want to acknowledge that we are grateful that this has happened and to accord the fact that the devolved Administrations have said that those aspects of the commission’s activities that are devolved will be subject to separate legislation, which I understand is at hand. To conclude, I welcome this development. Timetabling would be of interest and, obviously, assurances that it will happen and that we will not be left with a situation where outsiders, in effect, negate its efficiency. As a passing interest, many years ago I was for several years a member of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, an organisation for which I have huge admiration and was very grateful to be part of. It continues to produce valuable initiatives and support democracy and human rights, more vigorously than perhaps any other institution in Europe. I hope that the United Kingdom will continue to be a full and active participating member of the Council of Europe. As an aside to the Conservative Front Bench, I am concerned that the Conservatives are going down a path that could lead to Britain’s withdrawal from the Council of Europe if we were to withdraw from the European Convention on Human Rights. Support for the convention is a precondition of membership. I hope that that will not be the case, but I cannot leave this without saying that it is a concern.

More from Lord Bruce of Bennachie (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.