Contribution
My Lords, I thank the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Chelmsford for securing this debate. The right reverend Prelate asked what assessment the Government have made of the number of refugees who will be settled annually through community sponsorship. The honest answer so far, from what I can see, is that we do not know. In response to a Written Question that I asked on 5 October, the Minister said:
“The Government expects the total arrivals across the UKRS and the three new community sponsorship routes to number in the low hundreds at first”.
It is the words “at first” that concern me. What timeframe does that cover? Is it a few hundred people in the first year or the first three years? How many people do the Government believe will be able to come to Britain after this undefined initial phase? Do the Government even know how many people they want to bring into the country under these new schemes? The Minister must tell noble Lords how the cap will be set and by whom, whether Parliament will have a say, and what happens if the cap is exceeded. He must also say whether numbers will sit alongside a commitment to reduce overall migration.
Furthermore, in that same Answer, the Minister said:
“The Home Office works closely with the local authorities that volunteer to participate in the UKRS”.
Can I take that to mean that local authorities will have to house these refugees only if they volunteer to do so? If so, can the Minister rule out any local authority being forced to house refugees who enter the country under one of the new schemes if they do not wish to do so, or will we see a repeat of the current situation whereby local authorities have no say over where asylum seekers are housed?
The context matters. We are told that this scheme depends on illegal migration falling, so let us look at where it stands. More than 41,000 people crossed the channel in small boats in 2025. In the 12 months to June this year, around 33,000 did so. The Government point to a fall, and they are right that the number has fallen. However, 33,000 people in a year arriving in dinghies, in defiance of our laws and at the mercy of criminal gangs, is not a problem solved. The Government’s answer to this is to reopen the resettlement scheme, but to open the front door while the back door is still being forced open sends exactly the wrong signal to the people smugglers, the illegal migrants and, indeed, the British people.
What of the cost? The National Audit Office has estimated the cost of asylum accommodation at £15.3 billion over 10 years. Even after recent reductions, around 16,000 asylum seekers remain in hotels, and many thousands more are in other Home Office accommodation. Every one of those places is paid for by the taxpayer. The Government propose additional intakes and say that the sponsors will carry some of the burden. Can the Minister tell us what the total Treasury cost will be? What funding will be given to local authorities for school places, GP registrations and housing when a sponsorship arrangement falls through?
The Government’s policy of dispersing asylum seekers across the country has placed enormous pressure on small towns and rural communities that never asked to be at the centre of a national problem. Residents in places with one GP surgery and one primary school have found hundreds of newcomers placed among them with little warning and even less consultation. Local councillors and police have told us how hard it is to preserve cohesion in those circumstances. Whatever one thinks of the policy, those communities have a right to be heard. The Government are now asking those same communities to take on a further burden through sponsorship, and they are doing so before they have shown that they can manage the problem they already have.
Under these proposals, charities and non-profit organisations will be able to apply to become sponsors, and approved groups will be able to choose the refugees they support and take responsibility for their housing, integration and employment. That is a significant degree of trust to place in an organisation. Let me be plain: there have been a number of cases over many years of charities, mosques and NGOs that have hosted extremist speakers or whose trustees or associates have held views hostile to our way of life. The Charity Commission has opened statutory inquiries into such cases, and we have a duty to ask whether an organisation of that kind could become an approved sponsor with direct responsibility for vulnerable people who may depend on it for their housing, income and daily lives. This is even more important given that we know that the Iranian regime has been sending operatives to Britain on small boats. What is to say that they will not attempt to do so through the community sponsorship routes?
So I have a few specific questions to the Minister. Will every applicant be vetted against Charity Commission records and Security Service advice? Will trustees and key personnel be checked? Will there be ongoing monitoring, and will approval be withdrawn swiftly if concerns arise? Will the Government ensure that no sponsor, of any faith or none, is able to exploit a position of influence over refugees, whether to radicalise, to coerce or to profit?
We need a real assessment of the numbers involved in these schemes. We need a full costing of the policy, including the burden on local authorities. We need proof that the small boat crisis is under control before the legal routes expand. We need a commitment that communities will be consulted, not simply informed, and we need a rigorous, transparent vetting regime for sponsors. I look forward very much to the Minister’s response.