Contribution
My Lords, I thank the Minister for bringing the Statement to your Lordships’ House this evening and for the opportunity to ask questions on the Statement.
It has been over a year since the Government announced their plans to establish a “fairer pathway to settlement”. The Home Secretary is to be commended for having the courage to stand up to the open borders advocates in her own party and proposing the original earned settlement plans. I applauded those plans when they were announced last year. Although nowhere near strong enough, they were at least a serious recognition of the scale of the problem and what needs to be done to solve it.
When the original policy was released, there were no exemptions to the earned settlement route. Yet today we have heard that the Home Secretary has caved in to pressure from those same open borders left wingers on her Back Benches and in the unions. The result of this climbdown is that now over 250,000 low-wage care workers, and their dependents, will get to stay for a minimum of 10 years, with many getting settlement in five, and almost 75% getting to stay in the country for ever.
The costs of this reversal are significant. The Home Office’s document released last year revealed that the median salaries for care workers on the health and care visa were between £23,000 and £26,000 in the financial year 2023-24, which is significantly below the median full-time salary of £37,000. The OBR estimated that, as a result, they are likely to have a net negative fiscal and economic impact. This is because the amount of tax they will pay will never cover the amount they will take out of the system in NHS costs, education costs if they have children, and welfare claims. It is the British taxpayer who will pay for this policy reversal. That is in no way fair.
We have heard the arguments that this large cohort of migrants has “contributed” to our country, and, as such, they seem to have automatically earned the right to stay. But, of course, many of them have not contributed, at least not fiscally or economically. The Home Office itself has estimated the total cost of exempting care workers to be approximately £10 billion. If these workers intend to keep working in the sector, I would have thought there should be no issue with having to wait 10 to 15 years, like everyone else. It becomes an issue only if they are using that sector as a stepping stone to settlement, and ultimately citizenship, and are frustrated at being made to wait to leave their care job. They responded to economic incentives: they were given the chance to come to the United Kingdom to work and they took it. They are exactly the same as all other people who have come to our country on work visas. If the Government believe it is only fair to require settlement to be earned, it should be earned by everyone. Exempting this subset of people creates a double standard.
This is particularly true given that only 18% of those who responded to the Government’s consultation were British citizens; 73% of respondents were current visa holders. Yet the Government seem to have taken their opinions to be representative of the entire country. Well, of course people who are not British citizens would have negative views of the Government’s original policy, because they are the beneficiaries of the current regime. Unfortunately, we are now in a situation where our country’s immigration policy is being decided based on the views of those who are not even British citizens.
Bizarrely, the Home Secretary even said:
“I know that the people of this country wish to continue welcoming genuine refugees”.
We have a long history of generosity as a nation, whether that be towards Jewish refugees in the 1930s and 1940s or to families fleeing Putin’s illegal war in Ukraine, but I suggest that most people, given the ongoing rate of illegal migration, do not support additional routes through which more refugees will come to Britain. We must get overall migration down before we even consider any loosening of our policy.
It seems to me that there are those in the Labour and Liberal Democrat parties who would have us believe that ever having had a visa ought to give a person the permanent and irrevocable right to stay in the country. This is not how the system works, nor how it ought to work. Being granted a work visa, whether that be a skilled worker or a health and care visa, is a privilege, not a right. Similarly, being granted indefinite leave to remain is a privilege, not a right. Just because a person has been allowed to come to the country, that does not mean they have the automatic right to stay here indefinitely. So I wholeheartedly agreed with the Home Secretary when she said in her Statement:
“Settlement … has therefore been a right accrued with little expectation of responsibility. I do not believe that this represents true fairness”.
The problem, of course, that she has broken her own test with this climbdown, because now the Home Secretary’s test of fairness applies to everyone but care workers, which is not fairness at all.
It says in the A Fairer Pathway to Settlement document that this is not about assimilation. I disagree. Assimilation into British culture should be the minimum prerequisite for any settlement. As my right honourable friend the leader of the Opposition has said, completely correctly, we may be a multiracial country but we should not be a multicultural country. The so-called diversity of cultures is a recipe for disaster.
A healthy society is built on trust. A shared culture is the underlying source of mutual understanding between groups of people who have no other way of relating to one another. It is, in that way, a source of trust. Without a single, common national culture, and without the trust that flourishes from it, we risk undermining our future as a peaceful, harmonious and functioning society.
That is why the debate matters so much. It is not just the fiscal cost of the Government’s surrender on immigration, although that is significant. It is the long-term social and cultural impacts that matter too. On both these tests, the Government have demonstrably failed.