B

Baroness Jenkin of Kennington (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 29 October 2026

Debate

Personal Independence Payment and Disability Benefits: Implementation and Impact

Contribution

My Lords, I am grateful for this opportunity in the aftermath of the Budget to debate one of the most pressing challenges facing our country. I am grateful to all noble Lords who have stayed to debate it in the graveyard slot. This challenge, of course, is the sustainability of our welfare system and, in particular, disability benefits, including personal independence payment and the wider set of entitlements passported by PIP. The basic purpose of our welfare system ought to be straightforward. It is a safety net for those who need it, to help people who are out of work to return to employment where possible and to provide proper support to those who cannot work because of illness or disability. PIP has a particular role within that system. It is to cover additional costs associated with long-term disability or a health condition. That is a legitimate purpose, but we know that in practice it is not always how PIP is functioning. When we look at the disability benefits system more widely, there are serious questions about whether it too is fulfilling its objectives. We have a system that too often fails to provide people with the practical help they need, which can leave them dependent upon financial support, without addressing the underlying difficulties they face, and which, through its interaction with other benefits, can create uncertainty and financial disincentives for those who might return to work. Despite the increasing sums being spent, the Government have yet to demonstrate convincingly how they intend to bring the welfare bill under control while improving the effectiveness of the support being provided. PIP itself is a generously conceived benefit. It is unconditional, non-contributory, not means tested and does not need formal medical evidence. International comparisons by the TaxPayers’ Alliance show that PIP is a looser regime that also pays more generous rates than our nearest colleagues in the European countries we like to compare ourselves to. It needs skilled assessors who can discriminate effectively and maintain thresholds. Assessors need strong support from immediate managers all the way up to Ministers for some tough decisions, as well as appeal mechanisms that consistently apply those same thresholds. PIP was also designed before courts interpreted the relevant law as encompassing a wide range of mental health conditions, and before Covid and furlough normalised paying healthy people to stay at home and not work. Let us now have a look at the figures. As of July 2026, some 4.1 million people in England and Wales were entitled to PIP, of whom approximately 3.4 million were of working age. Some 37% were receiving the highest level of award, while over the preceding five years 42% of new claims made under the normal rules resulted in an award. According to Department for Work and Pensions statistics, 79% of planned award reviews resulted in an increase or no change in the award. For reported changes of circumstances, that figure was 89%. Meanwhile, 27% of mandatory reconsiderations cleared, excluding withdrawn cases, resulted in a changed award. These are substantial—indeed, enormous—figures. They make it all the more important that we understand what is driving the growth in claims, how eligibility is being assessed and whether the support being provided is producing the outcomes we should expect. PIP is designed to support people who find daily living or mobility more challenging because of a disability or health condition and there is an important question here about the distinction between recognising a condition and identifying the practical support that someone actually needs. Take, for example, conditions such as anxiety, depression or ADHD. We should also be asking whether the assessment system is sufficiently effective at distinguishing between different levels of impairment, identifying the additional costs people actually face and determining what form of support would be most beneficial. The current system presupposes that a cash award is the most appropriate intervention. But surely, with the substantial rise in those claiming benefits on the basis of a mental health condition, should we not consider that timely therapy, appropriate treatment, occupational support, workplace adjustments or other practical interventions may do far more to improve their quality of life, and indeed that they might enable some to return to work? The purpose of the disability benefits system should not be simply to recognise that someone is experiencing difficulty; rather, it should help them overcome that difficulty wherever possible. That brings me to how PIP awards are assessed and reviewed. The figures I just cited raise important questions about how consistently assessments are conducted, how effectively changes in circumstances are identified, and whether decisions are made correctly in the first place. Where a person’s circumstances have materially improved, there must be a fair and reliable means of recognising that change, and, where an initial decision is overturned, we must consider whether an avoidable error was made in the initial assessment. I would therefore be grateful if the Minister could explain what steps the Government are taking to improve the accuracy and consistency of PIP assessments and how they intend to ensure that reviews respond appropriately to permanent, fluctuating, and potentially treatable conditions. There is a related point here about face-to-face assessments. Can the Minister commit to restoring face-to-face assessments in their entirety rather than relying on assessments conducted over the telephone? If not, can she explain how the Government can be confident that they are accurately assessing an individual’s physical needs and their entitlement to support without ever seeing the person concerned? According to the Office for Budget Responsibility’s report yesterday, spending on sickness and disability benefits alone is forecast to reach £100 billion by 2028-29, a year earlier than forecast in March. That is up from £85.6 billion in 2025-26. These are very substantial sums, particularly at a time when public finances are under such considerable pressure, and they bring us to a fundamental point which is sometimes overlooked in debates about public spending: every decision about government expenditure is ultimately a choice about whose interests we prioritise and who bears the costs. This was made abundantly clear in the Budget debate yesterday. That is why fairness must be at the centre of this discussion—fairness not just to those receiving support but to those whose taxes fund it and to those who depend on the other public services competing for the same resources. This brings me to the question of incentives. We cannot consider PIP entirely in isolation from the wider benefit system. For people who receive PIP alongside other forms of support, particularly means-tested benefits, there is a serious question about whether the interaction between different payments creates the right incentives. For some people, returning to employment or increasing their working hours can mean a substantial reduction in means-tested support, at the same time as they face the additional costs of going to work. The result can be that someone takes on greater responsibility, works more hours and contributes more in tax but sees relatively little improvement in their disposable income. Where people are concerned that attempting to return to work or demonstrating an improvement in their condition might place their existing support at risk, that uncertainty can become a barrier in itself. There is something fundamentally wrong with a system that can leave people afraid that making progress in their life might result in them being worse off. We should want people to recover where possible, to become more independent and to enter or remain in employment where their circumstances allow. The welfare system should support those ambitions, not discourage them. If we want people to enter employment, work must offer a clear and worthwhile reward. It should not be the case that the structure of the welfare system itself discourages people from doing precisely what the country needs and wants them to do. What does it say about the fairness of our system when people who work hard, pay their taxes and contribute to the economy can struggle to see the financial rewards of doing so? What message are we sending when we ask those working families to shoulder an ever-greater tax burden while failing to demonstrate that the substantial sums being spent on welfare are delivering the best possible outcomes? Those people are increasingly impatient and intolerant about how their taxes are being spent. These are perfectly reasonable questions, which we should not shy away from asking. The welfare system ultimately depends on a degree of trust and shared responsibility. Those who contribute must have the confidence that their taxes are being spent effectively, support is going to those who genuinely need it and those who are capable of working are being given every reasonable opportunity and incentive to do so. Equally, those who depend on the system must have the confidence that it will provide them with proper support when they need it. For those receiving PIP, that means knowing that assessments will be conducted fairly and consistently, decisions will reflect their needs, and they will not be penalised simply for attempting to improve their circumstances. Those two principles are not in conflict. Indeed, I would argue that they are mutually dependent. Before I close, I have some straightforward questions for the Government. Are PIP assessments consistently and accurately identifying the practical difficulties that people face and the additional support they need? Are we sufficiently distinguishing between permanent disabilities, fluctuating conditions and circumstances in which someone’s health or independence might improve? Are the reassessment periods that we have sufficient to capture those people whose conditions improve, meaning they no longer require the benefit? Are we doing enough to connect people with treatment, rehabilitation and practical assistance rather than relying on financial payments alone? Are we ensuring that those who wish to return to work or increase their independence can do so without the fear of abruptly losing essential support? We cannot simply continue increasing expenditure without addressing these points. Nor should we allow legitimate proposals for reform to be dismissed as a lack of compassion for people with disabilities. We need a disability benefits system that protects those with the greatest needs, provides effective and practical support, helps those who can work to do so, and treats those who pay for it with fairness and respect. That is the balance that the Government should seek to restore. It is deeply concerning that they have yet to demonstrate either the political conviction or the practical plan required to do so. Until we see meaningful reform, we risk not only growing pressure on the public finances but a growing loss of confidence in the welfare system itself. Ultimately, it is those who depend most on that system who have the greatest amount to lose. I beg to move.

More from Baroness Jenkin of Kennington (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.