Contribution
I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Jenkin of Kennington, for securing this debate. I look forward to hearing other contributions and, in particular, the response to the debate from my noble friend Lady Dacres of Lewisham, whom I warmly welcome to the Front Bench.
I will particularly address PIP. The Motion goes a bit wider, but I think that it is really focusing on PIP. We will of course receive the final report of the Timms review next month, followed by a White Paper, and we expect legislation in the coming year. So, it is an appropriate moment for Parliament to discuss the principles that should guide reform and the questions to which the Government must provide convincing answers. The decisions taken over the next year will shape the future support for millions of people with disabilities.
The interim report of the Timms review reached a striking conclusion: although PIP remains highly valued by many who receive it, the system itself is no longer fit for purpose. The review drew on more than 38,000 responses from people with disabilities, charities, professionals and others, making it one of the largest exercises of its kind undertaken by the Government. More than 90% of responses concerning the claims process were negative.
Much of the public debate has focused on the rising cost of PIP. Costs matter, and no responsible Government can ignore them. However, figures on expenditure do not speak for themselves. They require proper analysis.
The overall case load at any point reflects three separate factors: how many people are making new claims, how many claims are being accepted and how many people remain entitled to the benefits. If we are to make sensible policy, we need to understand which of these factors is driving growth. Reviews and reassessments alone do not explain the increase that has been identified. There has been a genuine rise in reported disability and long-term health conditions, particularly among younger people. The interim review highlights the changing nature of disability and ill health since PIP was introduced in 2013 by the coalition Government. I therefore hope that the Minister will ensure that the forthcoming White Paper provides a detailed breakdown of case load growth, separating the effects of new claims, award rates and claim duration.
We also need to work on the quality of decision-making. The points-based descriptors that underpin PIP have changed little since the benefit was introduced. Throughout that period, they have struggled to deal properly with fluctuating conditions, multiple conditions and many less visible impairments. The result is a system that too often fails to capture the realities of the lives of disabled people. The consequences can be seen in the appeals process and the relatively high proportion of changes through that process. The most efficient way to administer any benefit is to make the correct decision at the outset.
This brings me inevitably to the question of fraud. Some recent media coverage has created an impression that abuse of PIP is widespread. That narrative deserves careful scrutiny. Stories about social media influencers explaining how to complete claim forms may generate headlines, but guidance on filling in what are, in truth, complex applications is not in itself fraud. What matters is what the department’s own evidence shows. The latest DWP estimates put PIP overpayments due to fraud at 1.4% of expenditure in the last fiscal year. That represents an increase and should be taken seriously. However, it also means that more than 98% of spending was not lost to fraud. The overall PIP overpayment rate at 2.3% remains below the average across the benefit system.
It is also important to understand the nature of the fraud that does occur. A substantial proportion arises where an individual’s condition has improved and the improvement has not been reported. This is plainly a risk where conditions may change over time. It is much less relevant where conditions are lifelong and progressive. Learning disability is lifelong by definition, and the same is true of many degenerative conditions, yet people with such conditions continue to undergo repeated reassessments. That was one of the major complaints exposed by the Timms review. More broadly, across all claimants, the great majority of planned reviews lead to either no change or an increase in entitlements. Those figures raise a legitimate question: are we directing administrative effort to the places where it is most useful? The sensible conclusion is not that everyone should be reviewed more frequently; it is that reviews should be targeted when needs are genuinely likely to change, while people with lifelong conditions should be spared unnecessary reassessment.
To turn to the review, many of the emerging recommendations point in exactly that direction. They include a redesigned, improved application process, improved treatment of fluctuating conditions, and the creation of an advocacy service to support claimants. These proposals are to be welcomed, but good intentions alone will not be enough. An advocacy service without adequate funding will achieve little, and better assessments will require assessors who understand learning, disability and other complex conditions. I hope the Minister can assure the House that both will be properly resourced.
The more significant question concerns the long-term future of PIP. The review is exploring a shift away from the current assessment of functional difficulty towards awards linked more directly to categories of disability-related extra costs, while retaining cash support as the foundation of the benefit and preserving its non-means-tested nature. There is an obvious logic here. PIP is described as a contribution towards the extra cost of disability, yet eligibility until now has been determined primarily by functional tests rather than by assessing the costs that people face. Aligning the assessment more closely with the purpose of the benefit has an intuitive appeal. However, Parliament should not endorse such a change without answers to some important questions.
First, there is the question of evidence. Extra costs can be difficult to identify and even harder to quantify. Many are indirect, intermittent or hidden. People who need support with communication, decision-making or money management may find it particularly difficult to document them. How will costs be defined? How will evidence be gathered? And how will the Government ensure that fixed categories do not exclude claimants whose circumstances fall outside a predetermined list?
Secondly, there is the issue of choice. The review suggests that some support could potentially be delivered through services or other non-cash provision. Services have a role, but they cannot offer the flexibility of cash. People with disabilities know best what support they need and any move towards non-cash provision should therefore be optional and claimant led.
Thirdly, there is the question of distributional impact. Reform has to operate within the government spending framework, but changes within a fixed budget inevitably create both winners and losers. Parliament will need to see detailed analysis showing the effects by condition, age and component of the award. That analysis should also consider employment outcomes. It is important to emphasise that PIP is not an out-of-work benefit; indeed, it is a benefit designed to directly enable people to work. PIP is payable both in and out of work and for many people it is precisely what makes employment possible.
The interim review has performed a valuable service by bringing together evidence and challenging assumptions. The test now is whether the Government respond to that evidence. Reform should be guided neither by expenditure figures in isolation nor by alarming stories in the press but by the realities of disabled people’s lives and by the goal of creating a system that is fair, accurate, sustainable and worthy of public confidence.