L

Lord Davies of Brixton (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 12 November 2026

Debate

Autumn Budget 2026

Contribution

It is a real pleasure to take part in this debate. Because of the time limit, I make an all-too-brief welcome to those who have made their maiden speeches and to one whose speech is forthcoming. I welcome the Budget in broad terms—a breathing space is welcome. Nevertheless, I have two questions for my noble friend the Minister on Budget measures where I think the Government have not gone far enough. First, while I welcome the announcement in the Budget of the changes in the surplus sharing arrangements in the Mineworkers’ Pension Scheme, it is ultimately the members’ money, and it is right that they should get their benefit. Nevertheless, it is unfortunate that the agreed transfer of the remaining guarantor’s fund has been delayed. I should mention that, in the past, I have advised the National Union of Mineworkers about these arrangements. May I press my noble friend to update the House on the position and give a commitment that the transfer of ownership will be made in a matter of days, rather than a period of weeks, as suggested by my right honourable friend the Chancellor in the Commons last week? All the administration is in place; the payments could and should be made to members before Christmas. The second question for my noble friend is whether the Government have considered collecting the income tax that is due on state pension benefits through PAYE. This question arises because of the introduction in the Budget of the pension tax allowance for the next three years. It has to be admitted that, given the problem they face, this answer is a bit of a bodge. The problem arises because income tax has never been deducted from payments of state pension—unlike earnings, they are outside the PAYE system—but tax is still due on pensions in excess of the personal allowance. This is not a theoretical point. Many pensioners have significant amounts of earnings-related state pension in addition to their basic and new state pensions that they accrued between 1978 and 2016. The result is that a large number of pensioners are already paying income tax on their state pensions. The fact that there are pensioners paying tax on their state pension is not new; it is just that there is now an increasing number of them, given the freeze in the personal tax allowance. It also means, crucially, that it is so visible: there is an easy comparison between the amount of the new state pension and the personal tax allowance, and the visibility of the issue has forced the Government into taking action. In such cases, where tax is due, it is currently collected from pensioners’ other sources of income—in most cases, from their private pensions—by adjusting the relevant tax code. This obviously poses a problem for low-income pensioners caught by the personal allowance with little or no other sources of income. The point I wish to make is that, had state pensions been subject to PAYE, the issue just would not have been as visible or as administratively complex and, hence, the pension tax allowance introduced in the Budget would not have been needed. In truth, it has been introduced essentially for short-term political reasons rather than as a desirable and logical part of the income tax structure. There is no real reason why pensioners with an income slightly over the personal allowance should have this relief and workers with an income slightly over the personal allowance should not be receiving equivalent relief. The problem arises from the freezing of personal tax allowances. The practical question we must answer is, given that this measure has been presented as a three-year fix, what happens at the end of that period? I suggest that extending PAYE to state pensions should be an important part of the answer.

More from Lord Davies of Brixton (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.