Contribution
My Lords, I declare my interests as chairman of Amey, of Acteon and of Buckthorn Partners. I also congratulate those who have made their maiden speeches and will make the maiden speech to follow.
The lifeblood of a healthy economy is energy that is cheap and, as my noble friend Lord Bridges said, resilient. Without it, we cannot compete and will not grow. Yet British industry now pays up to six times more than China for electricity and four times more than the United States. That is untenable. For all its talk, this Budget barely scratches the skin of the energy elephant in the Treasury.
When we left office in 2024, the UK’s fossil fuel dependency had fallen to 75%—a record low and a legacy we handed to this Government. Under Labour, our fossil fuel dependency has risen to 76.6%. That alone should have driven the Chancellor to maximise production from our own North Sea reserves instead of importing more. Domestic oil and gas production from the North Sea strengthens our defence and resilience. It brings in billions in Treasury receipts. It sustains jobs and growth. Most importantly, it produces far lower emissions than shipping in liquefied gas from the other side of the world to meet our requirement, which is unlikely to change in the medium term.
So why do the Minister and the Government dither over Rosebank? It is included in the OBR forecast, but it has not been approved. The Energy Minister in this House says that the OBR forecast would have to be ripped up and rewritten if Rosebank is not approved, yet, despite assurances, Rosebank appeared in neither of the last two OBR reports and has not been approved.
There is a contradiction behind this at the heart of government. Only yesterday, before the international tribunal in Hamburg, the Attorney-General argued that halting the Sea Lion field north of the Falklands in the South Atlantic would inflict “devastating” financial harm and cost billions essential to the islands’ development. Who signed that off? The Foreign Secretary signed off Sea Lion and now is known, unsurprisingly, as the Member for Port Stanley. He backed the 1.5 billion barrel new Sea Lion oilfield in the South Atlantic, yet calls the possible approval of Rosebank in our North Atlantic waters, which would be well under half its size, “climate vandalism”.
We need firm power, and we will need oil and gas for decades to come. Offshore Energies UK has identified 111 projects within existing licences that could unlock £50 billion of private investment. Why did the Chancellor not fast-track them? Why are we the only country in the world refusing to develop its own reserves at pace?
The consequences of high electricity and energy prices are already here. Two of the six remaining refineries have closed, on this Government’s watch. Ministers then went cap in hand for an exemption from our own Russian sanctions, so that we can import aviation fuel refined in India from Russian crude, while our own oil stays in the ground. That money fills the coffers of the Kremlin, which spends it on weapons used against the people of Ukraine, and that fuel is in the mix of every flight from London—from Heathrow and Gatwick—including the Prime Minister’s flight to COP 31.
Ministers tell us that our renewables are clean and homegrown. They are an absolutely important part of the energy mix, but they are neither clean nor homegrown. We import nearly 70% of our solar panels directly from China. Some 90% of the polysilicon in those panels is made in China from coal-fired furnaces belching CO2 emissions, in a country whose human rights record is under the spotlight. Global warming is a global problem. We cannot claim moral leadership in the UK while pretending that emissions begin only when products arrive on our shores.
When the Prime Minister trumpets the new Vanguard offshore wind farms at COP 31, let him tell the world the following: around 99% of the hardware will be imported from Denmark, Poland, Italy and Spain, with the rare earths and magnets made in China. It is we who should be building that manufacturing capability here and now, and that should be the Chancellor’s priority. It is no wonder that Gary Smith, general secretary of the GMB, called this Government’s energy department “the ministry for P45s”. He was right.
It is time to scrap the carbon taxes and adopt the Conservative’s cheap power plan. Without it, we will be heading blindly into a high-cost energy emergency, and households suffering from the high costs of living will be fortunate to get through this winter without power cuts.