L

Lord Sherbourne of Didsbury (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 12 November 2026

Debate

Autumn Budget 2026

Contribution

My Lords, yesterday, I reread the Budget Statement and was struck that for such an underwhelming Budget, the Chancellor used extraordinarily grandiloquent language. In particular, he boasted that the Government’s vision was “burned into every line of this Budget Statement”.—[Official Report, Commons, 28/10/26; col. 314.] Unfortunately, he did not actually tell us what the vision was. No doubt the scribblers in No. 10 are now having to work it out as they put together the 10-year plan, which I thought the Prime Minister had as he came into Downing Street. We have to wait, I think, until next year before we see the 10-year plan and the new economic model. The Budget was conspicuously absent of the model or the vision. I want to focus today on a certain obfuscation in the Budget. I had hoped to see a simple table setting out government revenue and government expenditure side by side. There is no such table. The Red Book has 150 pages. When you finally get to pages 149 and 150, you see two pie charts. That is the most you get of what I regard as the most fundamental thing of a Budget, which is revenue and expenditure. This is all part of the problem that Governments have, which is trying to disguise from people how much tax they are paying. I would have liked to have seen a table setting out what the tax burden was for families of different sizes. That does not appear anywhere in the 150 pages of the Red Book. We know that Governments of all parties, not just this Government, to be fair, want to hide from the public how much tax they pay. When you go to a shop to buy goods, you do not see the VAT. You do not know how much tax you are paying at the petrol station, unlike in America. If you are on PAYE, when you get your pay, you look at your net pay; you do not really see how much tax you are paying. Of course, when you are lifted out of a lower tax band into a higher tax band, there is no announcement that you are going to be paying more tax. It just happens to you. However, if you ask anybody how much they pay in council tax or for their TV licence, they will know exactly how much they are paying. I will give some figures. Average pay is about £35,000 a year. One-third of that goes on direct and indirect tax. In the 1990s, about 26 million people paid income tax. Today, it is about 40 million. I shall make a suggestion to the Minister and, through him, to the Treasury. Can the Red Book next year publish some very simple tables that ordinary people can understand, that I can find quickly and that can be reproduced in the media so that people know exactly what the Budget is doing to affect their lives? By the way, as the Government keep talking about the need to educate 16 year-olds when they get the vote, it would not be a bad idea to make sure that they understand what happens to their tax when the Government impose these changes. I want to raise one other point, about defence. I looked back at what John Healey said when he resigned as Defence Secretary. He said: “I am certain that a headmark date for 3% of GDP on defence in 2030 is what Britain must set. This commitment”— that was his word— “would have strong cross-party support”. He called for a commitment to spend 3% of GDP on defence in 2030 and complained that the Treasury was unwilling to commit the resources. Now that he is Chancellor, he can do it—but no, he has watered down the commitment to what he calls a “target”. He is simply calling for a target. A few days after the Budget, the new Defence Secretary, Wes Streeting, said: “I understand why John can’t at this stage say we are going to spend 3 per cent in 2030”. Well, he may understand it, but I do not. I am not sure whether the Minister does, but perhaps he could at some point explain exactly why we cannot be told that.

More from Lord Sherbourne of Didsbury (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.