Contribution
My Lords, the Committee will undoubtedly be grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, and the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler, for bringing forward these important amendments and for highlighting the vital contribution that unpaid carers make to our health and care system.
It is an obvious truth, but a truth worth stating, that carers are the people who know the person they care for best. They provide not only practical support but continuity, reassurance and an understanding of individual needs that can make a real difference to the quality of care. I very much welcome the recognition of the key role that carers play and the need to ensure that they are, first, identified—as many noble Lords have emphasised—and then listened to and appropriately involved in decisions about the people they support, while at the same time respecting the wishes and rights of patients themselves.
Carers are often family, friends and neighbours, and they usually do not foresee the duty happening upon them. They demonstrate the most admirable qualities in fulfilling that duty. The pressures that caring responsibilities can place on individuals and families are frequently very considerable, which is why we must never lose sight of the need to support carers’ own health and well-being, including opportunities to take a break from caring, as the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, mentioned.
Amendment 21 would enshrine the right of carers to be involved in patients’ decisions, which seems eminently sensible and right. Carers, with patient consent, already have the right to be involved in discussions with clinicians. At the same time, clinicians will always need to make a judgment according to the situation, because it is just as important to go back and check the wishes of the patient and to make sure, for example, that they have privacy when they want it. Without wishing to downplay in the slightest the value of these amendments, it would be helpful to have confirmation from the Minister that a patient has the right to withhold from a carer sensitive information in their medical records that they might not want shared.
We will be debating the Government’s proposals for a national care service in a later group, but I wonder whether the Minister can give us a sense of how the Government view the position of unpaid carers in the context of those proposals. In what way do they think a national care service could or should affect the status of family carers? I ask because, with the concerns that noble Lords have raised during the debate, it seems doubly important that we do not inadvertently sideline or devalue the extraordinary contribution to society, and indeed to the economy, that unpaid carers make, or overlook the practical support and respite that carers need.
Unpaid carers are the backbone of so much of our health and social care system. Carers can be of any age. My noble friend Lord Young of Cookham rightly emphasised the role of young carers. Their contribution is immense, as are the burdens they carry, yet so often those things go unseen. Caring is a profoundly challenging role that, over time, will undoubtedly affect a person’s mental and physical health. The support for carers that noble Lords have so often called for can come in different forms: the noble Baroness, Lady Watkins, referred to the vital importance of respite and the part that care homes play in providing it. My noble friend Lady Morris has just reminded us that there are many great charities operating in this field. I wonder whether the Minister could give us a sense of what the Government’s vision is for how such support and respite should be delivered: whether they see it as primarily a role for the state or whether there is a broader palette of provision that is right and sensible to avail of.
Whatever the future structure of our care system, we must not lose sight of the people who give so much to care for others. Their voices and needs must be recognised.