L

Lord Farmer (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 3 November 2026

Debate

Prison (Governor’s and Adjudicators’ Punishments) (Amendment) Rules 2026

Contribution

My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who have put their names down to speak and have made time to take part this evening. The Victims and Courts Act 2026 gave judges the power to impose in-prison punishments for non-attendance at sentencing hearing. The MoJ gave these new judicial sanctions a big push in the media last month when they were laid as the Sentencing Act 2020 (Prison Sanctions) Regulations 2026. I agree with the MoJ’s intent to make: “Cowardly killers who dodge sentencing face tough new prison punishments”. These punishments include no visits for up to 27 days and restriction of social visits to once every 28 days for up to 84 days. For these prison sanctions to have effect, the Sentencing Code requires that they correspond to the punishments that may be imposed by a governor under prison rules, so governors who oversee them need parallel powers—hence the Prison (Governor’s and Adjudicators’ Punishments) (Amendment) Rules 2026. These are the subject of my regret Motion because they give governors new disciplinary powers that do not correspond to judges’ very limited sanctions but far exceed them. Whereas a judge can restrict visits at the very beginning of a sentence, governors are now able to do so at any point to punish any offence. The prisoner discipline procedures adjudications policy framework sets parameters as to the seriousness of the offence but, first, these could change and, secondly, why are such sanctions generally available? Removing visits for non-attendance at sentence hearings is reasonable and hard to disagree with. However, the measure has been expanded beyond this initial justification and prison rules changed in a way that was not made clear during passage of the parental Act. The Government might claim they are being tough on crime, but at best it is an ineffective measure to that end and at worst a counterproductive measure. It is not being soft on crime to oppose it but the opposite. Social visits can restrain bad behaviour because prosocial relationships improve rehabilitation—the lack of such relationships is a criminogenic need. These are an individual’s characteristics, traits, problems or issues that directly relate to their likelihood of reoffending. Offender assessment system data says that 72% of all offenders in custody have a relationships need, and 80% of women in prison. Obviously, governors are immediately concerned with reoffending that happens inside their jails. This is the justification for making harsher punishments available. However, I saw during my first review for the Government how family visits can turn around dreadful behaviour. The mother of one young man complained to the deputy governor of a prison I visited about allegations of unfair treatment made by her son. The deputy helped her understand that the shoe was actually on the other foot. On her next visit this mother put her son right and told him to get a grip—his behaviour changed utterly. This anecdote is backed up by the MoJ’s own research on reoffending, which found that the protective factor of positive family relationships can moderate risk factors including having an attitudinal criminogenic need: a way of thinking, belief or attitude likely to lead to further offences. That young man would probably be among the 85% of male prisoners in that category. Prisoners who have family visits are significantly less likely to reoffend than those who do not. The old MoJ figure of 39% dwarfed the effectiveness of other rehabilitation pathways such as education, employment and drug treatment. It was the reason they asked me to do the reviews, first for the male estate and secondly for all female offenders. HMPPS’s commitment to implementing all my reviews’ recommendations since 2017 has gone far beyond words on the page. It knows that the greater prize is to shift the culture towards a greater emphasis on improving relationships, whether between officers and prisoners, between senior officers and junior officers they are mentoring or between prisoners themselves. The transforming prisons directorate is reconceiving prisons and designing new builds around the need for relationships. Yet, despite 10 years of progress, social contact is now a disciplinary sanction. The Prison Reform Trust says that this devalues family members, treats them as instruments of prison discipline and completely neglects the impact on family members despite them having done nothing wrong. Thankfully, those with children will not be so punished, but such prisoners already have a far greater incentive to keep out of trouble in prison. Category A prisoners in HMP Frankland told me they walk away from conflict because their families and children will hear of altercations and will want to know that they are safe. Indeed, I have heard that governors do not want to use this sanction as they see it as counterproductive to running a safe regime. The report on prison riots in 1989 by the noble and learned Lord, Lord Woolf, warned that messing with the ability of families to visit was one of the most resented acts the Prison Service could take. To conclude, this is the recurring problem that Governments of all colours face: how to appear tough on crime—which this is not—without turning our prisons into overcrowded places where rehabilitation becomes impossible. With attention on capacity pressures and early release, I fear measures are being introduced that make regimes appear tougher on crime but that are simply tougher on prisoners and more toxic to a rehabilitation culture. If this increases in-prison and community reoffending, our prisons will simply fill up. King and Willmott’s Honest Politician’s Guide to Prisons and Probation tracked 40 years of tough penal policy and the personalities responsible for crafting it. They found time and again that once politicians had moved on from the justice portfolio, they would acknowledge the futility of bowing down to public opinion instead of doing more to shape it. I am grateful to the Minister for making herself available to discuss this SI, and I wonder if there might be room for manoeuvre. The Government could rewrite and reissue it, so that removal of visits could be used only as the judge-imposed sanction for non-attendance at sentence hearing. This could be achieved by taking it out of Rule 55, covering governor punishments for any offence, and by following the example of Rule 55AB, which specifically requires a prisoner to pay for damage to prison property once found guilty. This could then be new Rule 55AC. I hope this will be considered and I beg to move.

More from Lord Farmer (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.