L

Lord Farmer (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 16 November 2026

Debate

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I will speak to Amendment 53, which has been co-signed by the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett, who cannot be in his place. It would insert a so-called parental relationship test into the welfare checklist and place a requirement on judges to evidence their reasoning for a decision based on all elements of that checklist. I also express strong support for the opposition to Clause 16 standing part of the Bill from my noble and learned friend Lord Keen and my noble friend Lord Wolfson. In November 2020, the MoJ launched, “a review of the ‘presumption of parental involvement’, to make sure the right balance is being struck between the risk of harm to children and victims, and a child’s right to have a relationship with both parents where this is safe”. The review was explicitly to ensure that, “any decisions made are rooted firmly in evidence”. However, as I said at Second Reading, evidence of poor practice around the operation of the presumption is not at all the same thing as evidence that the statutory presumption itself has caused or materially contributed to that poor practice. The review did not include evidence about the long-term outcomes for children where the effect of a court order is that they have no contact with a parent. As 84.6% of lone-parent families are headed by mothers, it is far more likely that they will be missing a father. Indeed, Millennium Cohort Study research found that although only 2% of children aged 11 had no contact with their biological mother, 11% were not in contact with their biological father. If this were extrapolated to the current UK population of children aged under 18, possibly around 1.6 million have completely absent fathers. That is a very large number to pronounce upon without having relevant research. What about their Article 8 right to family life and the UNCRC’s Article 9.3 right for children of separation “to maintain personal relations and direct contact with both parents on a regular basis, except if it is contrary to the child’s best interests”? Much academic research shows the lifelong benefits to children of high father involvement, including better emotional well-being, future mental health, higher levels of cognitive and social competence, greater capacity for empathy and social responsibility, higher self-esteem, social maturity, self-control and life skills, and better school adjustment, academic progress and workplace success in adulthood. We are in real danger of ignoring this research if we send the signal that both parents and both extended families are not that important. Women’s Aid reports that 69 child homicides over 32 years were associated with unsafe contact arrangements following parental separation. In exceptional circumstances, children do not benefit from contact with both parents. However, as we have heard from my noble friend Lord Wolfson, hard cases make bad law. Six years ago, the harm panel report that led to the MoJ review said: “To the extent that the courts’ pro-contact culture operates as a barrier to addressing domestic abuse, it serves to reinforce that culture”. This needs unpicking. The assertion that there is a pro-contact culture in the courts is challenged by senior judiciary. Also, we are in a different world now as regards addressing domestic abuse. Much of the evidence used by the review pre-dated the harm panel, yet significant advances have been made since 2020, such as updated practice direction 12J and the Domestic Abuse Act 2021. Notably, that Act raised awareness of, and outlawed, the many forms that abuse can take. Many researchers have found clear evidence of parents with care perpetrating legal and administrative abuse against non-residents’ parents, mainly fathers, where structures and processes of the legal system are weaponised by ex-partners as a form of post-separation abuse. How many fathers of the estimated 1.6 million children with no contact are victims of such abuse? This was not considered in the MoJ review. Neither was the effect on the pre-court space, a key target area for the presumption in 2014. Approximately 140,000 families with dependent children experience parental separation each year, affecting an estimated 280,000 children. If 62% of separating families do not use the courts, that is around 173,000 children for whom the rebuttable presumption is the starting ground. It is a vital bulwark against vindictive parents with care emotionally and psychologically abusing non-resident parents and, more importantly, denying children contact with both parents and with safe parents.

More from Lord Farmer (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.