B

Baroness Barran (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 16 November 2026

Debate

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Contribution

My Lords, it is a great pleasure to follow the wise words of my noble friend Lord Farmer. I very much support the spirit of his modest but very important amendment. I want to start by thanking the Minister for his very helpful letter that he sent me at the end of last week, which tried to address my concerns directly. I am aware that not all ministerial letters achieve that, so I put on record my gratitude to him and his team for having done that. I also thank the noble Baroness, Lady Neate, for adding her name to my amendments. I will briefly set out the purpose of my amendments and the gap they seek to address. I will start with Amendment 53A, to which my noble friend Lord Wolfson referred. My noble friend promoted me so many grades. At Second Reading, I debated whether to confess that my highest legal qualification was a law O-level, but he made me “noble and learned”, so I will roll with that in future. Amendment 53A calls for a long-term evaluation of the outcomes for children subject to child arrangement orders, with specific reference to the impact of Clause 16. In his letter to me, the Minister referred to the work of the Domestic Abuse Commissioner and her report on the family court review and reporting mechanism—an acronym I will not risk at this time of night. He pointed out his department’s commitment to fund the second phase of that research, which of course is very welcome, although I note the Domestic Abuse Commissioner’s disappointment that there is a gap in financial and economic abuse in that regard. The work of phase 2 of the family court review and reporting mechanism does not answer the question asked at Second Reading: to what extent will the removal of the presumption of parental involvement impact on the ability of children to have the involvement of both parents in their lives, where it is safe and beneficial to do so? The mechanism does not explore the extent to which that will impact on the longer-term relationships with the non-resident parent or analyse the long-term impact on the safety and well-being of children subject to those orders. I would argue, and I know others would agree, that a longitudinal analysis is really important. As my noble friend Lord Farmer said, we do not have good evidence of the impact of the court’s decisions on the lives of children, whether in the more than 55,000 private law cases heard every year or the much larger number that are resolved outside the courts. Amendment 53B looks at the importance of specialist support for victims of domestic abuse in these cases. Again, I note the Minister’s letter, which sought to reassure me about the funding and quality of the specialist domestic abuse support. He helpfully referred me to the target operating model for the child-focused courts and the statutory guidelines for the Independent Domestic Violence Adviser—IDVA—services. At this point, I am not sure whether I should declare an interest, but, around 2004, there was a document on my kitchen table that contained the definition of what an IDVA was. We got it on to one page; I am pleased to see that the Government have picked up on that. My amendment looks at the recruitment, retention, training, supervision and delivery of specialist support services and the appropriate funding to underpin that. On page 13 of the target operating model document, reference is made to the fact that referrals can be made to a specialist domestic abuse service with the consent of the victim, that children are “victims in their own right”, and that the provision of “specialist support for child victims of domestic abuse is currently limited but can be offered under the Child Focused Model and is something that we are continuing to explore”. Does the Minister have anything more to say about the department’s exploration, and does he see a possibility that children will have a right to support in the child-focused court model? It also talks about the provision of support in cases of counterallegations. Can the Minister give the Committee a sense of how frequently this has happened in the pilot courts and whether it has been handled effectively? One can see some of the challenges for a small domestic abuse service responding to both parties. Can the Minister explain the Government’s plans for training? Courts are highly technical environments, and I wondered what evidence there was from the pilot about the training needs. My amendment also talks about securing appropriate funding for these services. Page 14 of the target operating model document refers to funding from police and crime commissioners. Can the Minister update the Committee on how that will work once we no longer have police and crime commissioners? Page 23 of the document states: “Specialist domestic abuse services are introduced under the Child Focused Model … The local funding for domestic abuse services will depend on relevant private law receipts and the rate at which referrals are made to service. The funding for domestic abuse services within Child Focused Courts is provided by the Ministry of Justice and is a permanent requirement of the model”. Can the Minister explain how this works in practice? It sounds like there is a guaranteed element of the funding and then another portion linked to the number of cases heard. Can he confirm whether I have understood that correctly and whether the department has estimated how much funding will be needed once the model is rolled out and how that would split between the two elements—the guaranteed and the per-case element? More broadly, the document talks about funding for IDVAs to use the DASH risk assessment to make a “professional assessment and summary of risk and impact”, which will be provided by the IDVA to the child impact report author. I was honestly concerned to read this. I was very involved in the development of the DASH risk assessment. It was never designed to be a risk assessment; we spent a long time calling it a risk identification checklist. Its purpose was to identify cases that would meet the threshold to be referred to a MARAC, at which more information could be shared and the risk properly assessed. It is not a full risk assessment, and it was never designed to assess the risk to children. If the Minister shares my concerns, I would be more than happy to meet him at a more civilised hour to talk about this, if he thinks it is worth looking into. Finally, I express my strong support for Amendment 53C in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Neate, who I know will introduce it with great expertise.

More from Baroness Barran (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.