B

Baroness Lister of Burtersett (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 2 November 2026

Debate

Representation of the People Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I will speak to Amendment 6 in my name, which is a probing amendment that seeks to clarify the scope of Clause 2 by excluding secure children’s homes from the definition of “youth detention accommodation” for the purposes of the disfranchisement of 16 and 17 year-olds otherwise newly enfranchised. First, echoing my noble friend Lord Murphy, I emphasise that I very much support our manifesto commitment to votes for 16 and 17 year-olds in the name of recognising their value as citizens, as is the case in Scotland and Wales. I will return in a later group to citizenship education, which is so important. The issue raised by this amendment was brought to my attention by Mark Alexander, a doctoral researcher at Cambridge, on behalf of the steering group for the Unlock the Vote campaign at the penal charity Unlock. Although I believe that some prisoners should have the vote, that is not what this amendment is about, and I do not intend to spark a more general debate on that. It is about exploring why children serving custodial sentences in secure children’s homes, SCHs, should be denied the new right to vote, when the Government accept that residence in such a home is not of itself a basis for disfranchisement. I realise that young people in SCHs who are not convicted prisoners will not be disfranchised. The Minister for Democracy has made that clear, both in the Commons and in a letter to Unlock, and the Explanatory Notes recognise that children may also be residents in such homes for welfare purposes, so SCHs will accommodate both children who have the vote under Clause 2 and children who do not. The question raised by Unlock is whether it meets the Bill’s wider objectives that a conviction of a child should disfranchise them when they are accommodated in a welfare-oriented rather than a penal institution. The Bill is intended to increase young people’s engagement with democracy. The Government have described their objective as enabling young people “to find their voice and exercise their right to vote”, thereby, it is hoped, building long-lasting engagement with our democracy. These are objectives that I very much share. However, arguably, they sit uneasily with the exclusion of vulnerable children whom the state is seeking to rehabilitate and reintegrate into our society. Surely such rehabilitative education should include an appreciation of the importance of active citizenship and public duty. The issue is especially significant because the Government recognise that eligible children in SCHs will require tailored support to exercise their democratic rights. Arrangements are already being developed with the Department for Education to highlight the value of civic engagement and democratic participation in SCHs for some children but not others. There is a risk that a child being told that they cannot participate in democracy alongside their peers in the same home will feel a sense of alienation and disaffection that could undermine their rehabilitative journey. Rather than building their identity as active citizens, it could have the very opposite effect. I ask my noble friend the Minister, first, why a child serving a sentence in an SCH should be disenfranchised—thereby being treated them differently from other children in the same institution. Secondly, why should the distinctive welfare and rehabilitative character of SCHs not justify treating them differently from those in penal institutions? Thirdly, have the Government assessed the likely impact of this disenfranchisement on the rehabilitation and future democratic engagement of convicted children in SCHs? Unlock has raised a valid question on whether the justification given by the Government for the disenfranchisement of those children is sufficiently sensitive to the distinctive nature of secure children’s homes. I look forward to my noble friend’s response.

More from Baroness Lister of Burtersett (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.