Contribution
My Lords, I am grateful to noble Lords for bringing forward this group of amendments. They raise a number of important questions about the future of social care, ministerial accountability and the support available to those who depend on care services. Of course, although the previous Government proposed an integrated health and social care service, the British people decided not to give us a chance to deliver it. Therefore, when a new Government came in, they decided they were going to have a separate national care service. That deserves a number of questions to be asked. I fully respect the fact that there is a commission at the moment, but we do not seem to be getting much detail. We also know that you cannot fix healthcare until you fix social care, which is one of the many reasons why I tabled Amendment 180, and I will focus some of my comments on that.
We on these Benches recognise the importance of reforming the social care system. We understand all the reasons behind the proposal for a national care service: to raise the profile of social care, and to do many of the things that the other amendments in this group suggested to do so. To answer one of the questions from the noble Baroness, Lady Thornton—I feel like a Minister again, just as the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett of Manor Castle, did, but on the other side; I am happy to rehearse that if we are ever back in government—we will support the Government where they demonstrate that their proposals are affordable, sustainable and deliverable. We are not going to oppose for the sake of opposition. I hope the Minister will recognise that, as an Opposition, we have always tried to be constructive, particularly when it comes to health and social care.
While we welcome the Government’s ambition to improve social care, as I said, we remain concerned by the lack of detail. We have been told that the groundwork for this service will be laid during this Parliament and its establishment will take place in the next one, yet we know remarkably little about how it will operate in practice, what it will cost, whether the end of the triple lock will provide enough money to fund it and what it will mean for those delivering care.
All that Amendment 180 would do is require the Government, within six months of the Bill passing, to set out some intended functions and the scope of the national care service. We are not asking for a detailed funding plan for the next 15 years or anything like that—we just want a little more detail. This is a probing amendment to tease out a bit more detail from the Government and, hopefully, help them to clarify some of their thinking around social care and what the national care service means. What will the functions and scope of the national care service be? We are not yet clear about that. What about its relationship with the NHS? We are going to have not an integrated national health and care service but a separate national care service, so what does that mean for the interface between the National Health Service and the national care service? What about its proposed commissioning arrangements, its estimated costs and its sources of funding? As the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, said, what we are really asking is how it will all fit together. It is as simple as that.
My concern is affordability. The Government have indicated that the money will come from changes to the state pension triple lock, but that is not the same as providing an implementation plan. Has any assessment been made of what this new service would actually cost, what proportion of that cost will be met by central government and what responsibilities will remain with local authorities? We do not need a commission to answer some of those questions.
There is an important question about whether the savings anticipated from the triple lock will materialise in time to meet the ramp-up costs of establishing a national care service. As the Minister will appreciate, major reforms of this kind usually require an awful lot of up-front investment and then, in time, the annual costs hopefully will stabilise once the infrastructure and systems are in place. Is the Minister yet in a position to tell us whether the Government are confident that we will have sufficient funding available when it is needed? While I admire optimism, it seems to me rather optimistic to assume that the cost of establishing an entirely new service will neatly coincide with and be offset by the savings arising from the changes to the triple lock.
We must also be clear about what services the national care service will actually provide. We know that free personal care is not the same as free social care. Residential accommodation, nursing provision and other essential forms of support can represent substantial costs for individuals and their families. While the Government have provided some welcome clarification on accommodation costs, important questions remain on eligibility, the precise scope of support and the position of working-age adults who currently have care needs.
My second concern is the future of existing care provision. Our social care system is supported by a remarkable range of providers, charities, social enterprises, mutuals, co-operatives, family-run businesses and independent care providers, and they all provide essential services, often with deep roots in the community they serve. We welcome the Minister’s recent recognition that there will continue to be a role for different types of provider and that this will be commissioned at the local level, but we need to understand how that commitment will work in practice. Once again, is the Minister in a position to tell the House what the establishment of a national care service will mean for these existing organisations? What about the relationship with local authorities? Will that change?
As the noble Baroness, Lady Pitkeathley, said, there are important questions about the workforce. We all recognise the important dedication of those working in social care, as well as the millions of unpaid carers who provide indispensable support to their loved ones. We welcome the efforts to improve pay, training and career progression, but these commitments will have to be met with a credible assessment of their costs. In establishing the NHS workforce plan, will there be a corresponding national care service workforce plan? How will these two things fit together?