Contribution
My Lords, I acknowledge the Minister’s willingness to engage with Members across the House to explain the Government’s intentions with regard to this legislation. I express the hope that he will exhibit an equal willingness in answering the very particular questions that noble Lords have now posed with respect to the provisions of the Bill.
I propose that Clause 1 not stand part of the Bill. That clause will remove the right of a defendant to elect for a jury trial in the Crown Court in the case of “either way” offences. I must observe that I was concerned by the remarks made by the Minister for Courts and Legal Services in the other place. She said that
“we need a better system, one in which courts, not criminals, triage cases”.—[Official Report, Commons, 7/1/26; col. 284.]
Her characterisation of all defendants as criminals is concerning in itself. It suggests, I hope inadvertently, that Ministers have lost sight of the essential principle that a defendant is presumed innocent unless and until they are found guilty. That principle cannot be lost sight of simply because of a backlog in the Crown Court. I hope the Minister will be able to clarify the remarks made by the Minister in the other place and to reassure us that the principle of presumption of innocence is not being pushed aside just for the benefit of convenience and timing.
On these Benches we will always stand up for the ancient right to trial by jury. It has been a fundamental protection against arbitrary justice for hundreds of years, and it has stood the test of time. More generally, the Bill seems to be driven more by ideology than by evidence, and that is a point to which we will return. Throughout the 2000s, the then Labour Government brought forward a number of Bills that sought to undermine the right to trial by jury. This House opposed such measures then, and we on these Benches oppose such measures today.
The Government have failed to justify their proposals with clear evidence. Indeed, I noted the observations of the noble Baroness, Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb, that the Government are pressing ahead without evidence. The noble Lord, Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames, noted that the evidence in support of these proposals is “painfully thin”.
We have tabled this stand part notice because we need to hear from the Government what evidence there is that these proposals will reduce the backlog in the Crown Court system and are the only necessary route to achieving such a goal. In the absence of that evidence, we remain sceptical about the impact of these proposals. If the Minister could point us to the relevant evidence in his closing remarks, I would be grateful.
Is there evidence that these proposed reforms will reduce the Crown Court backlog in one year, in five years, in 10 years or, more likely, never? If the backlog is cleared, does the Minister accept that the Bill should be repealed? If the size of the backlog is the sole reason the Government are seeking this legislation, surely the absence of a backlog will render it unnecessary. Will the Minister answer that point?
In addition, it seems likely to us that these measures will simply move the backlog from the Crown Court to the magistrates’ court, as other noble Lords have observed. Clearly, other groups in Committee will address the issue of the magistrates’ courts, so I will not linger or expand on that point at this time. However, how much do the Government expect these measures to impact the magistrates’ system and what measures are being taken to avoid that system being overwhelmed by these measures?
Amendment 1 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Chakrabarti, signed by the noble Baroness, Lady Goudie, alongside my noble friend Lord Hailsham, probes whether the representations of defendants with good character who have not previously been convicted of a crime could be given greater weight. We acknowledge that this is an interesting point, and the noble Baroness is right to question how the treatment of defendants will differ based on their criminal history. It is important to consider whether a defendant with previous criminal history is more likely to receive a jury trial, so I look forward to hearing the Minister’s response.
Amendment 2, in the names of the noble and learned Lords, Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd, Lord Burnett and Lord Phillips of Worth Matravers, and my noble and learned friend Lord Bellamy, seeks to question what guidelines will be provided as to the allocation of “either way” offences. Clearly, Clause 1 contains a substantial change to the way in which such offences may be tried and there has to be a consideration, if Clause 1 stands, as to how such guidelines would operate.
Amendment 3 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Chakrabarti, again signed by my noble friend Lord Hailsham, and Amendment 7 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Hamwee, seek to question the appeals process. I hope that the Minister will again consider those points and the concerns that have been expressed regarding the appeals system.
Finally, Amendment 5 in the name of my noble friend Lord Young of Acton seeks to exempt offences relating to contested speech from the provisions of this clause, so that a defendant’s right to elect for a trial by jury can be maintained. My noble friend makes compelling arguments defending the importance of freedom of speech, and today was no exception. Although I acknowledge his concerns, it might be unusual to make an exception for only one type of offence, but he raises an important point in recognising the value and importance of the jury. I hope again that the Minister will respond to the points made.