Contribution
My Lords, this has been an important and informative debate about a fundamental part of the Bill. Given that there is opposition to Clauses 1 and 2 standing part, I will take a moment to set out the principal reasons for them and deal with some general points that have been brought up in the debate, and then I will deal with the specific amendments.
Clause 1 will remove the defendant’s ability to choose to elect for a Crown Court trial for all triable “either way” offences so that venue decisions are made solely by the courts. In doing so, it redresses the balance between victims and defendants by ensuring that they are based on the seriousness and complexity of the case and not the defendant’s preferences. Clause 2 is consequential on Clause 1 and ensures that the written plea procedure will operate consistently with the wider reforms once commenced.
We have heard contributions about confidence in the justice system, particularly in the context of jury trials. My noble friend Lady Chakrabarti and the noble Baroness, Lady Jones, have raised these issues, while the learned and noble Lord, Lord Keen, raised the presumption of innocence, another foundational principle. The Government are concerned about public confidence, and that is a reason why we are bringing forward the Bill. Those clauses will ensure that Crown Court time is prioritised for the most serious and complex cases, ensuring a more proportionate use of limited court resources and sparing victims unnecessary delays.
Magistrates’ courts are fair, robust and independent, and these clauses recognise that. Safeguards remain: both prosecution and defence can make representations on venue, and defendants retain full rights of appeal to the Crown and High Courts. Fundamentally, the Government do not believe that a defendant should be able to override the court’s judgment and secure lengthy delays in the hope that victims and witnesses walk away and the case falls apart before it is heard.
Some general points that have been raised include concerns about magistrates, particularly the complement of magistrates. This was raised by my noble friend Lady Bi, the noble Lord, Lord Macdonald, the noble Baroness, Lady Hamwee, and the noble and learned Lord, Lord Keen. We are increasing the numbers: we have a target to nearly double the complement of magistrates from a historic low in 2022 by 2028-29. Noble Lords will hear more detail about this from my noble friend Lord Lemos during this Committee, so I will not spend time on it just now.
I wish to address the request for evidence from the noble and learned Lord, Lord Keen—indeed, it was raised by more than one person. Again, my noble friend Lord Lemos will deal with this subject in more detail, but detailed modelling has been published by the Ministry of Justice showing the impact on the backlog of the measures. I am happy to point the noble and learned Lord in its direction and share it with him.
Before I turn to specific amendments, I want to address the question from the noble Baroness, Lady Hamwee: what is the collective term for noble Lords of nobility and learning? I wonder if I might suggest “a wisdom” of noble Lords, or indeed “a wisdom” of noble Baronesses —but perhaps others can suggest different terms as the debate goes on.
Amendment 2, tabled by the noble and learned Lord, Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd, would require the Secretary of State to issue statutory guidance on the allocation of “either way” offences. He acknowledged that this is a probing amendment. I will address the points that he has raised, and indeed I hope to continue the conversation with him beyond this. The noble and learned Lord raised the question of judicial input. The Sentencing Council is currently the body that issues the guidance that is used. That council is chaired by judges; it has judicial membership and indeed it consults judges. It is of course an independent organisation, which is an important safeguard.
The further question that was raised was: should the sentence be determinative of the factors taken into account? Sentencing is not the only factor, but I acknowledge that it is significant. The noble and learned Lord raised important points that were raised also by the noble Lords, Lord Macdonald and Lord Marks. This debate is a good opportunity for us to consider these issues, and I would be happy to continue the conversation after today’s Committee.