Contribution
My Lords, I begin with the words of the noble Lord, Lord Russell of Liverpool, who explained in his remarks that he comes to these issues from the perspective of victims, as indeed does the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton. That sentiment perfectly encapsulates how the Government come to these issues too, so I hope that we can find a way to make common cause.
The amendments in this group relate to distinct topics, so I will address them in turn, starting with Amendment 47A, from the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton. I was grateful for the opportunity last week to meet the noble Lord, Lord Marks, and the noble Baroness, Lady Hamwee, who raised with me, among other topics, Amendment 47A. I am sorry that the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, could not join the meeting last Friday; technical challenges prevented it—and affected several million other people at the same time.
I recognise the concern for ensuring that expert witnesses who provide evidence in criminal proceedings are appropriately regulated and qualified. However, it is the Government’s position that the existing Criminal Procedure Rules and Criminal Practice Directions provide proportionate standards for judges to consider when determining the admissibility of expert evidence. This includes requiring expert witnesses to be competent and for their opinion to be sufficiently reliable. In determining this, the court can take into account any lack of accreditation to prescribed standards where it might be expected.
Experts are required to provide qualifications, experience and accreditation to the court, and to provide notice of anything which may detract from their credibility. Expert witnesses must also sign a declaration of truth, confirming that they have complied with their overriding duty to provide an objective and unbiased opinion to the court.
In any event, we would have concerns about the practicalities of listing a designated regulatory body for every applicable profession in secondary legislation. The amendment’s requirement for this secondary legislation to undergo the affirmative procedure would make it difficult to keep this list relevant and up to date. Indeed, as the noble Lord, Lord Faulks, alluded to, some experts may not fall neatly within its categories. I have certainly been involved in cases where some rather unusual experts were involved but who were, none the less, very helpful to the court. The system needs to be flexible to account for such instances. The current regime provides proportionate safeguards while giving flexibility to the court in admitting evidence which will provide judges and juries with information outside their knowledge.
Amendment 47B, also from the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, seeks to extend Clauses 8, 9 and 10 so that they apply in all cases where there is a victim within the meaning of the Victims and Prisoners Act 2024. The purpose of Clauses 8 and 9 is different from that of Clause 10, so I will take them separately. Clauses 8 and 9 are designed to address specific evidential issues that arise in sexual offence prosecutions. They reflect recommendations from the Law Commission’s review of evidence in sexual offence cases, which identified the continuing impact of myths and misconceptions on trials for cases of this kind.
These clauses focus on two specific tropes that have been shown by the Law Commission, as well as the Crown Prosecution Service, to be regularly admitted without sufficient evidential basis in sexual offence cases: first, that previous allegations are false and the complainant is a serial liar; and secondly, that applications for criminal injuries compensation are made with the intent of using victimhood for financial gain. The clauses introduce an elevated test of admissibility for this type of evidence. Similar evidence introduced in other offence types would still be required to meet the standard test of relevance or the admissibility criteria for non-defendant bad character evidence. We do not have the evidence to justify an elevated admissibility threshold across the full range of criminal offences. If the noble Baroness has any evidence or information that we are unaware of, I would be pleased to meet her to discuss this. Indeed, I would be pleased to meet her in any event—and perhaps we will do it in person this time.
Clause 10 serves a different purpose. It specifies that previous domestic abuse offences of whatever kind can demonstrate a propensity to commit a domestic abuse offence. This is the approach taken with child sex offences and theft offences. Expanding Clause 10 to other offences would have limited effect. The existing bad character framework already permits previous convictions for any offence to be admitted where they demonstrate a propensity. The issue in domestic abuse cases is that abusive behaviour can manifest through a wide range of offences. This has led to inconsistency in the admission of such evidence, and Clause 10 seeks to provide greater clarity in that regard. For those reasons, the Government do not consider it appropriate to extend Clauses 8 to 10 in the manner proposed by this amendment.
I recognise the concern of the noble Lord, Lord Russell of Liverpool, about ensuring that victims have meaningful access to justice where prosecutorial decisions to terminate cases have been wrong, which is expressed in Amendment 49. I am grateful to the noble Lord for meeting me last week to discuss it. The noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, made clear her support for this amendment. It would extend far beyond rectifying errors and would make fundamental changes to how all Crown Court cases may be terminated, not just those subject to a victim’s right to review. This would have significant implications for victims, defendants and the entire criminal justice system. Allowing prosecutors to terminate cases at a later stage without a verdict, while retaining the ability to institute fresh proceedings for the same offence, would extend the uncertainty inherent in discontinuance to defendants whose cases have progressed further through the Crown Court. It could also leave victims without closure and bring an end to the protection provided by any bail conditions or remand in custody relating to those discontinued proceedings.
Additionally, reinstituting cases would require fresh proceedings beginning back in the magistrates’ court, which risks creating further delays for victims and significant inefficiencies, contrary to the purposes of our criminal court reforms. However, we sympathise with the issue that the noble Lord seeks to draw attention to. We hope a better solution is the Government’s commitment to getting it right first time as an approach to supporting victims’ rights. I welcome the practical steps the CPS has taken towards this, such as increased senior oversight when terminating serious sexual prosecutions and the early victims’ right to review pilot in the West Midlands, which the noble Lord referred to, which has shown promising results. The Government will continue to work with partners on this. I am pleased to confirm to the noble Lord that the early victims’ right to review scheme has been rolled out to every CPS area across England and Wales from 13 July this year, and the feedback so far has been very positive.