B

Baroness Smith of Cluny (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 16 November 2026

Debate

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Contribution

I am grateful to the noble Baroness for raising this, because it gets to the heart of the question and the point of principle that these measures have been brought forward to address. At present, you have a full rehearing. That is not simply an attempt to deal with the miscarriage of justice; it is a full rerun of the case—another bite of the cherry. Miscarriages of justice are perfectly adequately taken care of in a proper appeals system, which is what we are seeking to bring in. There is no reason why there should be an automatic right of appeal just because you do not like the decision, even if it is without merit. The system that we will introduce will align with the system for serious crime and ensure that, where things have gone wrong in a trial, an appeal is appropriate. I will deal with the specific question asked by the noble Lord, Lord Murray, which was also mentioned by the noble and learned Baroness, Lady Butler-Sloss: why are we not waiting for the Law Commission to report before bringing forward these measures? We welcome the Law Commission’s work on criminal appeals, but the project was commissioned in 2023, before the review of the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson, into the criminal courts and the proposed reforms in this Bill. Its consultation therefore did not take into account wider changes in the criminal courts, which will bring more cases into the magistrates’ courts, thereby potentially increasing the volume of appeals to the Crown Court. However, the Government have engaged, through our officials, with the Law Commission on our proposed changes to magistrates’ courts appeals. It really comes down to a point of principle. Quite simply, you should not be entitled to a full rehearing of your case; you should be entitled to an appeal if something has gone wrong and there is a point of law to be argued. Before I move on to more specific amendments, I will deal with the question of litigants in person, which was raised by a number of noble Lords, particularly the noble Baroness, Lady Fox, and the noble and learned Baroness, Lady Butler-Sloss. I reassure the Committee that we are mindful of the impact of these measures on litigants in person, and I give an assurance that this is being looked at and thought about carefully. Amendments 40, 41 and 42 seek to broaden the test for permission to appeal from the magistrates’ courts so that the Crown Court must grant permission when it is in the interests of justice. The test for granting permission in the proposed legislation is based on the well-established test used in the Court of Appeal: is it reasonably arguable that the appeal will succeed? It will not generally be in the interests of justice to hear an appeal where there are no reasonably arguable grounds for appeal. Including an interests of justice test in addition is, we believe, unnecessary. A court might hear an appeal in the interests of justice where a party seeks an authoritative, binding judgment on a particular legal question. Under the rules of legal precedent, the Crown Court cannot provide a decision on the law that is binding on magistrates’ courts generally, whereas the High Court can. Appeals by stated case to the High Court would therefore be a more appropriate route for an appeal in this circumstance. Amendments 43, 44 and 45 from the noble Viscount, Lord Hailsham, seek to introduce a right for defendants to make oral representations to support their application for permission to appeal. I note that the noble Lord, Lord Marks, supported this as well. We anticipate that permission to appeal will be granted on the papers in most instances, but we recognise that an oral hearing will sometimes be necessary for the Crown Court judge to determine whether to grant permission to appeal. That is why we have a provision in new Section 108A in Schedule 2 so that judges can hold an oral hearing where they feel it is necessary, for example to seek further information on the issues identified in the permission application. The key here is whether it is necessary to hold an oral hearing, which a judge is best placed to determine. This amendment could create a situation in which Crown Court time is routinely taken up by hearings that are not required. Amendment 46 seeks to ensure that audio recordings and transcripts are available to appellants seeking permission to appeal and to all other parties. In the Crown Court to Court of Appeal, copies of audio recordings are not provided to parties, although arrangements can be made to hear the audio recordings, and transcripts can also be made available, as we have heard. Our measure allows for this. Schedule 2 to the Bill inserts new Section 108S into the Magistrates’ Courts Act 1980 to provide that rules of court can be made concerning the production of audio recordings and transcripts, and that transcripts can be provided to any persons. The existing legislation is therefore broad enough to allow for the provision of transcripts and the hearing of audio recordings through the Criminal Procedure Rules, in line with practice in the Court of Appeal, with no legislative amendment being required. Amendments 37, 65 and 73 from the noble and learned Lord, Lord Thomas—spoken to today by the noble and learned Lord, Lord Burnett, and supported by the noble and learned Baroness, Lady Butler-Sloss—respectively seek to ensure that the new appeals process is properly supported before it is commenced. Amendment 37 lists essential delivery requirements, not optional extras, and I reassure the noble and learned Lord that implementation planning is well under way. We are already working closely with the judiciary, the Judicial College and His Majesty’s Courts & Tribunals Service to ensure that sufficient magistrates, district judges and legal advisers receive the necessary training before implementation. Recording facilities in every magistrates’ court are a critical part of our reforms. HMCTS has piloted recording in seven courtrooms, with the evaluation informing our plans for national rollout. We will ensure that these facilities, alongside transcription services, are in place before commencement to support appeals. We will also ensure that sufficient administrative support is available to Crown Court judges. HMCTS is developing staffing and operating arrangements to ensure that support is in place from day one. However, flexibility over how that support is organised is necessary, so it should not be prescribed in primary legislation. I have heard what has been said about the practicalities in the debate this afternoon. The noble and learned Lord, Lord Thomas, spoke of a national office and the need for the necessary administrative arrangements around the triaging to be sufficient—and we hear him. Indeed, points about measures to ensure that sifting is undertaken, with appropriate safeguards, made by the noble Lord, Lord Pannick, were also well heard. Pertinent points have been raised today, and I assure noble Lords that they are heard.

More from Baroness Smith of Cluny (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.