L

Lord Jabbar (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 10 November 2026

Debate

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Contribution

My Lords, this is an area in which I am particularly informed by my own professional experience assisting defendants and appellants in court matters. I declared my interest at Second Reading as the executive director of the Death Penalty Project. I want to make a small comment. Effective defence representation is not peripheral to an efficient criminal justice system; it is one of the things that makes the system efficient and possible. At Second Reading, I distinguished between access to court and access to justice. Getting someone to a courtroom more quickly is of limited value if, once they are there, they cannot obtain proper legal advice, understand the proceedings or participate effectively. There is also a practical point. A properly prepared lawyer can identify real issues early, deal with evidential problems, narrow what is evidently in dispute and help ensure that a case is ready to proceed. That benefits the defendant as well as victims, witnesses and the courts. When a hearing is ineffective, everybody loses: court time is wasted, victims and witnesses may have attended unnecessarily, and practitioners have to return, and another case then goes back to an already overcrowded list. This is why I have considerable sympathy with the amendments. Criminal legal aid is not simply about remuneration; it is part of the infrastructure of the criminal justice system. If we want cases to be resolved earlier, we need effective advice early. If we want trials to proceed when listed, we need advocates who are available and properly prepared, and, as my noble friend Lord Shamash said, they must be sufficiently remunerated so as to attract lawyers to the work. We need the next generation of lawyers and practitioners who want to be involved in these kinds of cases. If more serious work moves into the magistrates’ courts, as discussed earlier, that work does not become less serious or less complex just because the venue has changed. I support the Government’s objective in reducing delay. It is precisely because I want these reforms to succeed that I regard sustainable legal aid and effective representation as part of the reform programme.

More from Lord Jabbar (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.