Contribution
My Lords, I welcome the inclusion of Clause 20 and the Government’s decision to provide an independent review of the impact of these reforms. At Second Reading, the Minister spoke about the importance of monitoring the outcomes and impact of the reforms. He also spoke more broadly about the breakdown in public confidence in our criminal justice system and he made it clear that these are intended to be principled reforms, not reforms based simply on expediency and efficiency.
The significance of these reforms is precisely why I particularly welcome the commitment to review their impact on particular groups and sectors. We are changing the rules that will affect how people experience the criminal justice system and how justice is delivered to them. When we do that, particularly where there is a possibility that those changes may have different effects according to race or socioeconomic circumstances, we assume a particular responsibility to understand those effects.
Socioeconomic disadvantage is not simply something we record about somebody’s background; it can shape their experience of the justice process itself. Somebody living in poverty or insecure employment, with limited literacy or education, or somebody from a particular racial background, may experience exactly the same form of procedure very differently from somebody who understands what is happening or does not suffer from the same disadvantages. This is why access to effective legal advice and representation matters, and it is why effective participation matters. I made that very clear in day 1 of Committee. Can the defendant really understand what is happening? Can they understand the decisions they are being asked to make? Can they engage properly with their lawyers and participate effectively in the proceedings against them?
However, disadvantages do not necessarily present themselves in convenient, separate categories. Somebody may be economically disadvantaged and may also have a learning disability or a mental health difficulty, limited literacy or a communication need. These vulnerabilities intersect and can compound one another. There is an important difference between applying the same rules to everybody and ensuring that those rules operate fairly for everybody. My concern is that, unless we monitor those effects carefully and in a timely manner, we risk introducing a further degree of arbitrariness into the system—a new process that has a very different impact on different people, not because of the merits of their case but because of the particular combination of disadvantage or vulnerability with which they encounter the criminal justice system.
We know from the data that there are already disadvantages within the criminal justice system. The question before us is what new obstacles are created by the changes we are now proposing. I am not suggesting that every difference in outcome amounts to unfairness, but a fair criminal justice system must be capable of recognising those differences without allowing them to determine the quality of justice that somebody receives.
If race, socioeconomic disadvantage and a lack of representation or vulnerability begin, separately or in combination, to affect a person’s ability to understand the process, participate effectively or exercise their rights, this should concern us. A system perceived to operate arbitrarily helps nobody caught within it—neither defendants, victims or witnesses—and ultimately undermines public confidence in our system to deliver justice fairly and consistently. Clause 20 should provide an important mechanism to check and correct. It allows us to ask not simply whether these reforms are working but how they are working and whether the impact is fair.
I want to mention one more important point. The two-year and five-year reporting period gives useful structure to the formal review, and this is to be statutorily imposed, but monitoring cannot begin and end with those reporting dates. If a significant racial or socioeconomic disparity begins to emerge some months after the operation of these provisions, or if there is evidence that suggests that particularly vulnerable defendants are struggling to participate effectively with the new arrangements, we should not wait two years, much less five, before paying attention to them. Monitoring should, and I hope will, begin when these provisions come into force and continue as they operate. I welcome the recognition in Clause 20 that significant reform should be accompanied by serious scrutiny of its consequences. Monitoring and learning, and, where the evidence requires it, adapting, must form part of responsible reform and is an essential safeguard to any system of justice that these reforms are ultimately intended to secure.