L

Lord Jay of Ewelme (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 11 November 2026

Debate

Surviving Drought (Environment and Climate Change Committee Report)

Contribution

My Lords, it is always good to follow my good friend the noble Lord, Lord Frost —opposites attract, I think I might say. It has been a pleasure to be a member of the Environment and Climate Change Committee for the last two years and to work with the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, as a highly effective chairman, and with our excellent staff. As our report makes clear, climate change is one of the key factors causing drought. I will just say a word about climate change itself: it is of course an international, not a national, crisis that we face at the moment. Despite the difficulties at present, in particular in Washington and elsewhere, it is essential that the international community takes climate change seriously, not least at COP 31, which is going on as we speak. I must say that I am not sure that flying a thousand people to Turkey is a particularly good example to the rest of us—an online COP might be an option for the future—but, even so, I am glad that the Prime Minister and other Ministers will be there and I hope that, at COP and thereafter, the United Kingdom will lead by example in what it says and does. Climate change is not of course the only cause of drought in the United Kingdom. Population growth and water-intensive industries, notably data centres, play their part too. Nor is drought an annual occurrence. None the less, drought in summer and flooding in winter looks like becoming, if not the new normal, at least a regular occurrence, hence the relevance of the committee’s report. It is clear from the Government’s response to the report that the Government and the committee are broadly on the same page. That is not always the case, in my experience, on this committee or others. I therefore welcome the publication of A New Vision for Water earlier this year and the report by Sir Jon Cunliffe that preceded it. As the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, said, however, it is execution that matters. I want to focus on two main issues, the first of which is the need to make us all realise that water is a scarce resource. We know when electricity is scarce because the price goes up and we know when gas is scarce because the price goes up. We use less electricity and gas as a result. We all know, I think, that the electricity price is too high and that the Government are rightly trying to get it down. However—I know this is an unpopular thing to say—the price of water is too low by any standard and we use it too liberally. I know how hard it is to raise prices at a time of economic difficulty for people and for businesses, but does the Minister accept that at a time of scarcity the price of water may need to rise? I know that the price mechanism is not everything, and I applaud the Government’s campaign earlier this year, “Let’s Save Water”, as an attempt to change attitudes in England and Wales. The chief executive of the Environment Agency, Philip Duffy, told the committee this morning that the early signs suggested that the report had had a positive effect. It was an impressive evidence session and the suggestion of a positive impact is good, but can the Minister tell us how the Government intend to maintain the momentum to change attitudes to water and to use less? Like others, I urge the Government and the committee to keep the pressure on the water companies to reduce leaks. Nothing so disincentivises the rest of us to cut back on water use than seeing the street outside our houses running with water from a burst main. I turn to the need to preserve water, a matter for all of us as individuals. Many of us are using less water and some of us are mastering the technology of rain butts. It is also a question of building regulations, and I am glad that the Government accept our recommendation on this. It is more than that though: too much rain is running into rivers and out to sea. We need more and deeper reservoirs, as mentioned by the noble Lord, Lord Sikka. I know the difficulties in winning local support for new reservoirs, but I do not see how we can meet the challenges and crises of the future without building them. The Government have talked of simplifying planning rules and the water companies have talked of compensatory measures for affected communities, but progress is worryingly slow. Can the Minister assure us of the Government’s determination to see new reservoirs built and used soon? We need large reservoirs but more on-farm reservoirs too, as others have said. I am glad that the Government accepted the committee’s recommendation on this and announced in August this year their intention to encourage local water supply and streamline planning barriers. But does this go far enough? The Country Land and Business Association makes a powerful case for constructing many more reservoirs than would be possible with the £15 million so far allocated by the Government. Like others I am sorry that we no longer have the Earl of Leicester with us to make this point more effectively than I can. Does the Minister agree that we must do much more? Finally, as mentioned by the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, we had excellent presentations from six schools during our work on this report. One of them gave us the title of our report, reclaim the rain. Their commitment was palpable, and it is their future and not just ours that is at stake.

More from Lord Jay of Ewelme (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.