B

Baroness McIntosh of Pickering (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 11 November 2026

Debate

Surviving Drought (Environment and Climate Change Committee Report)

Contribution

My Lords, I am delighted to have joined the committee in January 2026, which was part-way through the inquiry, and it is a privilege to serve on it. I declare my interests: I am co-chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Water Group and vice-president of the Association of Drainage Authorities, and I have minor shareholdings in Pennon and United Utilities. I co-authored four reports, and am now undertaking a fifth, on water and flooding policy in a series entitled Bricks and Water with Rob Allen from Westminster Sustainable Business Forum. I congratulate my noble friend Lady Sheehan for her excellent stewardship of the committee, for chairing it so well, for this excellent inquiry and for securing this debate. I echo the thanks of all on the committee to the support staff who are with us today. The summer of 2026 saw the worst drought for 50 years. The impact on consumers, farmers and businesses was palpable. In North Yorkshire, we had ongoing wildfires that were very difficult to control. They threatened farms, livestock and livelihoods. I praise the North Yorkshire Fire & Rescue Service and other emergency services for their huge efforts to bring those fires eventually under control. It is essential to have access to water for livestock, poultry producers, the horticultural sector and households. Climate change is now a fact of life. We have to learn to live with the consequences. We have to do more between droughts and between floods. It is essential that we store more water in times of flooding. We need to have not just the large reservoirs but, as others have said, smaller on-farm reservoirs of around 20,000 cubic litres. We need to have nature-based solutions, and I pay tribute to the Pickering Slowing the Flow pilot scheme project, which, in storing water upstream, has protected the town of Pickering from flooding since its construction. We must have measures to mitigate and adapt to the impact of droughts and floods. We need to use building regulations intelligently and effectively to make houses more resilient. We need to reduce water consumption per household to 105 litres per person per day. This is not unique to the United Kingdom: Denmark and other Scandinavian countries are already well ahead in this field. In considering the report, I will refer to certain recommendations and, in particular, the Government’s response to them. First, the committee recommended that water companies be made statutory consultees on all major planning decisions, particularly for houses. Why is this important? In the Pitt review in 2007, Sir Michael Pitt recommended ending the automatic right to connect, so that water companies would not be forced to make false connections or connections that would put undue pressure on wastewater—sewage—in adjacent developments to those for which planning permission was sought. Sadly, the Government have rejected that recommendation, which in my view is ill advised. Far too often, planning for major housing developments is being sought in inappropriate places—on functional flood plains and in areas of water stress. Also, too often, wastewater in the form of raw sewage is making its way into rivers, watercourses and the sea because these developments are proceeding against the advice of the Environment Agency. The Government have also yet to implement Schedule 3 to the Flood and Water Management Act 2010, allowing excess surface water to continue to enter the combined sewers. This situation will continue until water companies can formally reject inappropriate applications as statutory consultees. We proposed to strengthen building regulations to reduce potable water demand to a maximum water usage of 105 litres per person per day. Although the department has accepted this, the Government—and the Budget, as we heard earlier from the noble Lord, Lord Frost—have announced that no new building regulations will be adopted any time soon. That is very disappointing indeed. Internal drainage boards—I have declared my interest—have an essential role to play in the maintenance, drainage and flood prevention of watercourses in low-lying areas. Crucially, the role of IDBs should be recognised in the forthcoming water Bill so that they will have a recognisable role to play in any catchment management system of watercourses. Bizarrely, the department has rejected our recommendations to expand the remit of IDBs. On storing water, creating reservoirs, the use of abstraction licences, environmental permitting and nature-based solutions, Defra is ambivalent. It accepted our recommendation of moving abstraction licensing into the environmental permitting regime, but we heard from the Environment Agency today that there is simply no timeframe to do so and therefore, it seems to me, no sense of urgency. Given the scale of the problem identified in this report, I would argue that urgent action is needed and we need to do more to prepare for future droughts and times of flooding. Small on-farm reservoirs should be given priority. The department urgently needs to address the issue of the Balmforth review on reservoir safety and the de minimis rule contained in the Reservoirs Act 1975, recognising that small on-farm reservoirs of between 20,000 and 100,000 cubic metres simply do not threaten public safety—when they are ring-fenced so that no one enters them and drowns—but will manifestly contribute to preparing for and surviving future droughts. I urge the department to act now to implement all our recommendations or give us today a very good reason for not doing so.

More from Baroness McIntosh of Pickering (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.