Contribution
My Lords, I am most grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, for bringing this debate and for the thorough report by the Environment and Climate Change Committee. As always, it is a privilege to follow the noble Baroness, Lady McIntosh. About 15 years ago, when I was chairing the forestry and woodlands advisory committee for the Forestry Commission in the north-east, I visited Pickering to see that excellent work holding the water higher in the catchment area. I think beavers would also do a good job. There are two environmental areas on which I would like to focus: the impact of drought on soil health and chalk streams.
First, I shall offer a few reflections as a Lord spiritual. Drought is a recurring theme throughout history, bringing hardship, uncertainty and a stark reminder of humanity’s dependence on the natural world. My question is: has this been the hottest summer on record or the coolest summer of our futures? Has this been the worst harvest on record or the best harvest of our futures? The Bible offers some striking descriptions of drought and its consequences. The prophet Jeremiah describes the distress of people sent to draw water only to discover that the cisterns were empty. Similarly, in the story of Elijah the brook dries up because there had been no rain in the land. These accounts illustrate how quickly the things we take for granted can disappear and how vulnerable human life becomes when essential resources become scarce.
We should resist viewing drought as simply an act of nature beyond our influence. Climate change, excessive consumption and the pressures we place on natural resources all invite serious consideration of our responsibilities. We are reminded that water is precious, that its availability cannot be taken for granted and that we have a duty to protect and preserve our environment for future generations. I recall a time in the very north of Ghana when there was very little water, and we were given basically a calabash each to wash in every day. It was a salient reminder of how water in so many places around the world is utterly treasured.
Drilling down into the two areas of soil health and chalk streams, we are totally reliant on six inches of soil to sustain human life. Healthy soils store water, support plant growth, provide habitats for countless organisms and play an important role in maintaining the balance of our ecosystems. When soil is rich in organic matter and has a healthy structure, it can absorb and retain moisture, as the noble Lord, Lord Krebs, outlined, helping plants and crops withstand periods of dry weather and, vitally, holding water higher up in its catchment—a sort of natural flood management infrastructure. Conversely, compacted, depleted or degraded soils struggle to hold water, making the effects of drought more severe. As a simple experiment, pour water on to hard, dry soil, and it just runs off; pour it on to healthy soil, and it soaks in. Spongy soils are good, as the noble Lord, Lord Krebs, said.
Drought causes a slowdown of the soil microbe activity that drives nutrient cycling and supports plant growth. Microbial communities’ structure, function and interactions can all be disrupted in periods of drought. Drought also leads to nutrient stagnation. Without moisture, nutrient transport to roots halts and uptake by plants decreases. Drought impacts soil invertebrates—earthworms, woodlice, millipedes and the like—reducing population numbers, and this results in less supply for their predators and a greater challenge for birds to extract them from the soil.
The depletion of soils means that during drought conditions, soils become exposed to wind erosion as well as topsoil erosion when it rains too hard, causing flash floods. When, as we have heard, peaty soils dry out, carbon is released into the atmosphere, and they become susceptible to fire, as we saw with moorland fires last summer. The soil moisture deficit in west Norfolk at the end of September compared with the long-term average reached an all-time high of more than 160 millimetres.
Perhaps the lesson of drought is not simply that we need more rain but that we need to take better care of the ground that receives it. A healthy future begins under our feet. Improving soil health and having spongy soils is the first practical step towards greater drought resilience. Thus, my first question to the Minister is: where does soil health come in His Majesty’s Government’s priorities about responding well to a drier summer future?
My second point is the impact of drought on chalk streams. These precious ecosystems, of which about 85% of all the world’s 200 chalk streams are found in England, well up out of aquifers. Consecutive months of below-average rainfall mean that aquifers fail to recharge during the winter. Drought extends the time when there is no flow in winterbournes—temporary streams in the upper reaches of chalk stream systems that contain water only when groundwater levels rise high enough to feed the channel—thus threatening species that depend on these seasonal patterns.
The River Pang in Berkshire dried up in places never seen before this summer. In fact, poor old Ratty, Mole and Mr Toad would not be able to get into their boat. It is not helped by the level of abstraction to meet water demand. In August, the River Wensum, which flows through the centre of Norwich, experienced a mass death of fish and of species that are not visible—the fish all floated when they died, but many other species were killed as well—after a heavy downpour of rain flushed contaminants out of the city’s drains into the Wensum. Thus, my second question to the Minister is will His Majesty’s Government fulfil their promise in the White Paper to further “embed action” to protect chalk streams, including during periods of drought, in the long-expected clean water Bill?