Contribution
My Lords, this Budget is an important step on the painful journey to tackle Britain’s deep-seated economic problems and to create, I hope, a sustainable and growing economy. The Prime Minister’s first bold move was to reform the triple lock, much canvassed in this House, by increasing pensions in line with wages. This will save £50 billion by 2050, but none before 2030. The Chancellor’s decision to resist the temptation to change the fiscal rules has been well received by the financial markets and rewarded by a softening of yields on government debt and a reduction of the so-called moron premium inherited from the previous Government. A bank tax has funded a number of small but important and well-received measures to help the less well-off, the high street, some SMEs and entrepreneurs.
Overall, a key fiscal measure, the current balance—the difference between the current year’s government borrowing and spending—has fallen from a deficit of 2.5% in 2024 to a deficit of 1.5% in 2025-26, and is forecast to be in surplus in 2028-29, another UK achievement praised in the recent IMF report. The Chancellor has continued the vital work of his predecessor to increase the chronically low level of public investment which has placed the UK at the bottom of the G10 over the last 30 years. Public investment has increased since 2024 from 2.5% to 3.5% of GDP to provide a useful boost to profit.
I welcome the decision to devolve many of the capital investment decisions to the regions, which will have a better understanding of what is needed locally. But the increase in public investment, whether it is centrally or locally, reminds us that despite the excellent work of the infrastructure commission, the Government have a dire record of oversight of many capital projects; for example, the runaway cost of HS2 and the 20-year underspend on maintenance in the water industry. Beefed-up oversight is needed and should be provided by an independent, professionally staffed body with full statutory powers to investigate the projects, many of which are protected by their sponsoring ministry.
Private investment has also increased by 7.5%, but high energy costs, elevated interest rates and a heavy regulatory burden present stiff headwinds. The Chancellor’s commitment to delink the price of electricity costs from the market price of gas can reduce our energy costs, which remain the highest in Europe, but so far, the benefits of the measure to reduce the regulatory burden remain elusive.
Major challenges lie ahead. The results of the assured process of reforming welfare benefits to move funding from benefits to training are imminent. The Chancellor’s reaffirmation of the target to invest 3% in defence is welcome, but the funding plan will not be available until next year. That spending plan is also forecast to deliver an overall 2.6% reduction in spending, to be found by a challenging cut of 10% in non-protected areas.
The heart of the 10-year plan must be a radical plan for growth based on innovation, the measured adoption of AI and investment in skills. It must include tax reform to remove the many barriers to business growth; it must reform personal tax and benefits to make it fair and progressive and to reward productivity. The decision to freeze personal tax thresholds in 2022 means that each subsequent year more people are dragged into paying higher tax. An additional 1 million people this year will be paying more tax on their earnings, which have generally increased barely enough to meet inflation. On top of that many lose benefits. It is an unfair system which particularly affects the low earners, but it acts as a major disinvestment to all.
In my career, I helped to draft and deliver a number of long-term plans in both the public and private sectors. These plans were never short of ambition but, crucially, their success depended on early implementation. No plan can be delivered unless the necessary reforms and the tough financial decisions are tackled in the first 12 months. If that first year is done well, hope can indeed be transformed into reality.