Contribution
My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Hollick, and I also look forward to the maiden speech of the noble Baroness, Lady Ussher, and the other maiden speakers.
I had a certain sympathy with the Chancellor giving his first Budget at very short notice in a difficult situation. But if the purpose of the Budget was simply to bring some much-needed calm and not to frighten the horses, I can see that he might have considered his first Budget something of a success. The huge number of very small measures—over 90—were largely performative, designed to show ordinary voters that the Government hear their concerns. The Government would have been pleased that a poll after the Budget showed that 42% of the public judged the Budget fair.
But other people will have judged the Budget by differing criteria. Performative measures are not enough; there has been criticism of the dangerous lack of urgency in not addressing the challenges of defence, welfare and, above all, debt interest. The Minister has made much, not for the first time, of the IMF praise for the Government’s so-called deficit reduction strategy. But this strategy simply reflects the unreality of the fiscal rules which allow the Government to profile a declining deficit by writing in unrealistic spending and tax figures for the final year of the rolling plan. It makes no difference whether that plan is three years or five years. Paul Johnson, the former director of the IFS, said that the figures add up because the figures are made to add up.
The Government have chosen to reduce the deficit more slowly than planned by the Conservative Government. In Rachel Reeves’ first Budget, the deficit for 2026-27 was put at £89 billion, up from the £69 billion expected by Jeremy Hunt. By March of this year, the deficit had become £116 billion; now, it is £132 billion, much the same as last year. As one critic put it, this is deficit reduction “on the never-never”.
The biggest problem facing the country is the rising cost of debt interest. This makes us poorer as a country. This year’s £15 billion was added to what was expected to be paid in interest this year. If the same thing happens again in the next financial year, it could wipe out completely the fiscal headroom which the Chancellor has already reduced. This is a huge risk.
The fiscal situation also finds its reflection in the prospects for living standards which the OBR projects to be hardly any higher at the end of this Parliament than at the beginning. The chief executive of the Government’s favourite think tank, the Resolution Foundation, has said that living standards will not rise without public spending cuts, and the choice is whether household incomes or spending departments take the cost of adapting to the debt interest.
At least this Budget did not impose the whacking great tax increases we have seen in the previous two, but I very much regret the 2% increase in the tax on savings on top of the 2% already planned and announced. If we want to have a high level of investment, surely we ought to encourage savings, which the OBR projects to fall drastically. High-saving countries tend to be high-investment countries.
There are some grey holes in the Government’s spending plans. It seems that part of the gap in defence spending is going to be met by some sort of international partnership, by which the private sector leases equipment to the defence department. It sounds all too like the PFI all over again; sometimes it seems as though the Government want to PFI the whole economy. By changing the debt target from public sector net debt, or PSND, to public sector net financial liabilities, or PSNFL, the Government have created a powerful incentive for themselves to channel public expenditure through the National Wealth Fund, the British Business Bank and the National Housing Bank. These institutions now have close to £200 billion capacity, which barely registers in the official figures for the national debt. These debts may be called assets, but will the loans be repaid? Will these state funding bodies make a profit? The record from the past is not encouraging.
To conclude, this is a Budget for Mr Micawber. It is a missed opportunity. It solves nothing and I fear that, alas, we will be back looking at the same problems again.