L

Lord Eatwell (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 12 November 2026

Debate

Autumn Budget 2026

Contribution

My Lords, it is an honour to follow the noble Lord, Lord Neri, and to congratulate him on his important maiden speech. I declare an interest: my wife is a prolific commissioner of new music and two of her commissions have recently won an Ivors Composer Award. I therefore cannot help but be particularly pleased to welcome to your Lordships’ House the chief executive of the Ivors Academy, who made those wise decisions. The noble Lord, Lord Neri, has had a remarkable, productive career in the music industry, culminating in the Ivors job. He has represented the well-known and he has supported the unknown, always in the cause of creating great music. He has also deployed that expertise, as we have heard, in the service of those trapped by dementia, who could be liberated by the medicinal power of music. I am sure that the whole House looks forward to the noble Lord focusing his creative energy on debate in your Lordships’ House. Having listened to his important maiden speech, we now know that we have much to look forward to. Now to the Budget. Embedded within it is a potentially powerful growth model built on the two fundamentals that drive investment. The first is support for the growth of demand from a 14.6% increase in public investment this year and from targeted public procurement. Without the prospects of growing markets, investment will falter. It is no accident that the growth of business investment is highly correlated with the growth of public investment. The second major component is the provision of finance for investment. This is predominantly via the uplift in the lending capacity of the British Business Bank by £5 billion and the National Wealth Fund by £15 billion. That £20 billion boost will be multiplied by private funds bailed in by the public commitment. This investment by public financial institutions is crucial because it is focused on real investment in equipment, research and innovation. This is in stark contrast to the so-called investment of the majority of UK financial institutions that typically amounts to bidding for shares in secondary markets with little discernible impact on real capital formation. This persistent private sector failure to finance investment in real productive capacity also comes at a time when British bank lending to non-financial companies has fallen to a level last seen in 1998. Small and medium enterprises have been particularly hit, with SME loans almost halved over the last 15 years. Real investment grows when there is a prospect of growing demand and funding is available—hence the important role of the venture capital funding that the British Business Bank and National Wealth Fund seek to stimulate. But—there is a but—there is a limiting factor in this growth model: the venture capital industry in the UK is far too small. Only around £8 billion was invested in venture-stage businesses in 2025, compared with around £250 billion in the US, where the venture capital industry is over 30 times bigger than ours in an economy that is just eight times bigger. No wonder so many successful British SMEs seek their scale-up funding in the US. British innovation vanishes into American ownership because of the persistent failure of UK finance to back British creativity on the scale that is needed. The importance given to the British Business Bank and the National Wealth Fund in stimulating private sector investment is a recognition of that persistent failure; they do a valuable job, but they are too small. Their work is also hampered by the cultural risk aversion of the UK public sector. If the UK is to attain the higher growth performance it needs and to enjoy the lead in the technologies of the future that it deserves, then radical innovation is required in UK financial services. UK private sector financial expertise must be committed to real investment to creativity, innovation and scale-up. Allow me to illustrate what I mean by radical innovation. Today, regulators demand specific capital and liquidity commitments on financial institutions’ balance sheets. These regulatory requirements are defensive; they are designed to make financial institutions more secure and reduce risk-taking. Suppose a new requirement is introduced that encourages risk-taking: as a condition of having a banking licence, all banks in the UK with a balance sheet in excess of £100 billion would be required to commit 1% of their balance sheet to venture funding, either by venture funding themselves or by investing in venture funding companies. The result would transform not only the scale of venture funding available to the UK industry but the commitment of private sector expertise to venture funding and, to attain the 1% necessary, the risk appetite of UK financial institutions—an enhanced risk backed by huge balance sheets. To reindustrialise Britain, the funding of real investment requires radical reform. This is one way it could be done.

More from Lord Eatwell (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.