L

Lord Howell of Guildford (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 12 November 2026

Debate

Autumn Budget 2026

Contribution

My Lords, it is an honour to follow the noble Lord, Lord Eatwell. He is a distinguished economist, although, of course, economists never agree. There is always a dialogue between us. We have had some sizzling maiden speeches. I was very glad to hear the noble Baroness, Lady Ussher, say that she was a full-blown Keynesian, or had become one. When I arrived as a student at King’s College, Cambridge, Keynes had been dead a few years, but his spirit was just around the corridor. No conversation could take place without people saying, “Maynard says this” and “Maynard says that”, and often there were wrong interpretations of what he said. I remind your Lordships that he was against the conventional economic theories of the day, particularly those about balancing budgets and so on, and argued that you could get to a better, more purposeful and more stable society, in which there would be more investment and a better social atmosphere, if some of the tighter rules that economists were for ever laying down were disregarded. I think he would be saying exactly the same today, though obviously not on the same points, because what he said in the 1930s would be very inflationary now. However, I think he would point out that the economists are once again putting us in a prison over the alleged size of the fiscal headroom—whether it has drained down or gone up, and what it does to confidence and the bond markets. There is a lot of theory spinning around that seems to stand in the way of common sense in these matters. I will come back to that in a few seconds if I have time. The Governor of the Bank of England, Andrew Bailey, says he can “see the argument” for further rises in interest rates. Presumably he can also see—I hope he can—the case for lower interest rates, which might become available in response to a significant cut in state spending and borrowing. Of course, he believes—as he is entitled to do, as an independent operator—that that is a hopeless cause and a pipe dream in the present political and world climate, and that he has only one unpalatable route forward. He is right that the options are extremely limited. In the public debate, they seem to have been reduced to talk about cutting welfare—no one is too specific about the timescale, as it is very difficult—or doing without adequate defence. Again, no one is too specific about what that now means in the conditions of modern warfare, or how we defend ourselves against 100,000 or 1 million drones or unstoppable high-velocity rockets. The figures are certainly very daunting. As we know, the bill due this year just to service the national debt is set to be £133 billion, apparently rising to £160 billion in a couple of years. That is 4.2% of GDP. One wishes that the governor and others would see the argument for an altogether less costly and damaging pathway to stability. It seems that this black and white, bipolar, binary approach to the whole of our present dilemma ignores by far the most promising and achievable option of all, which is hardly discussed: starting here and now with a systematic and sharp shift—I think one noble Lord mentioned this earlier—of specific functions away from the hopelessly overloaded state and into new methods of co-operation between private funding, investing and enterprise on the one hand and public needs on the other. These are devices and new methods that many countries around the world are now trying, including a better version of PFI. I know that PFI has a bad reputation here, reflected in my noble friend Lord Lamont’s speech. Nevertheless, countries such as Japan, Sweden, the United States, Poland and Turkey—the list goes on—are trying new, more constructive methods of combining private resource with public needs. That is not all. Billions of state payments in the UK are index-linked directly to the retail prices index or the consumer prices index. It is hard to measure exactly which, as there are many complications, but there is a large compulsory addition to state spending for every extra increased point, or fraction of a point, in interest rates. This is a fruitless debate, leading us nowhere. Is something missing? Yes, I think there is. What is missing is a readiness to bring forward the schemes that are being tried all around the world for whole programmes, services and commitments to be taken off government accounts altogether. Other nations are doing it. The sceptics will say it cannot be done, but it is already being done in numerous other advanced economies and I hope the Treasury is watching closely.

More from Lord Howell of Guildford (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.